Wednesday, May 19, 2010

If loving Grace is wrong, I don't want to be right ...

The only thing worse than being wrong is being right.

Sister Margaret McBride can probably speak to this issue better than I.

A member of the ethics committee of St Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center in Phoenix, she consented along with other Doctors and professionals to allow an abortion because a patient’s life was endangered by continuing the pregnancy.

For that she has received the harshest of penalties – excommunication from her church - because of that choice. Only someone who has “married” themself to the church can fully appreciate what this has cost her.

Bishop Thomas J. Olmsted said that "the direct killing of an unborn child is always immoral." He is absolutely right of course. Sister Margaret did something wrong, and the church is unquestionably right to reprove her.

I myself cannot imagine the horror of facing such a choice – trading a woman’s life for her child’s (assuming that the baby could have been saved, which is not certain). It is an appropriate outcome in such cases, according to Bishop Olmsted, that the mother should die. To which there is also a certain horrible but inescapable logic.

Doing the right thing is not always easy. And this is what should happen in a world ruled by anyt sense of what is right, undeniably, irrevocably, and always right.

Who cannot appreciate the desire, even the need to live in such a world, with clear-cut rules and orders and categories. It is our constant search, our constant debate. And as long as we never face such choices as Sister Margaret, it seems an appropriate and fine way to live.

But then again.

Consider the ranging battles in the church today, the driving desire for the right, to erase wrong, to stand clearly on the side of God and His Word and stem the rising liberal erosion of value, of rightness. Is it not true that the Bible clearly tells us homosexuality is sinful, and if so, are we not obligated to stand firmly against it, in defense of marriage and pulpit? Churches are bleeding members and congregations for the lack of this simple rule: there is no place in the church for tolerating gay and lesbian marriage or ministry. None.

And shouldn’t then this always be our modus operandi? If we are called to the place about right and wrong then we will stand with integrity and power over and against all manner of sinfulness, wherever it is clearly proclaimed by Scripture and Tradition. We shall eradicate our pews of adulterers and fornicators, of liars and cheaters, of the irreligious and the intemperate.

People who forsake the speed limit on the freeway. Students who cheat on tests at school. Employees who take pens or post-it notes home from the office. Pastors who look at their Facebook page during office hours.

Do you know where this ends? I do. With Sister Margaret McBride and her awful, unimaginable, choice. Divorced from the church we love and the God we need.

Though it seems at first blush not to be, the fact is that Bishop Olmsted surely had a choice, too. What he did in excommunicating Sister Margaret was affirm the Law of God, the primacy of righteousness, and the authority of the church. What he did was turn his back of Jesus Christ.

For the sake of being right he forsook grace.

And we live daily in danger of doing so, too.

Someone recently reminded me that there are many, many people in the church who are angry and frustrated, who fear the direction of the church in its unwillingness to stand correctly against things that must be wrong. Someone recently reminded me that to many people this doesn’t seem like their church anymore.

Which it is not. Nor has it ever been. This is the church of Jesus Christ, who rules his kingdom in a very different way.

Being right is a powerful anchor, a steady foundation in the stormy seas of a difficult and confusing world. But like all weights, it is also the force that holds us down, turns us against one another, keeps us from rising above the real powers of sin, death and the devil, restrains us from the very Grace of God. Being right is the power to drown our church, each other, ourselves. Being right is very death.

It was Luther, finally, who reminded us, that the gift of Grace is a more wonderful “daily drowning” in baptism, the collapse of our search for righteousness until all that remains is a healthy dependence of the Grace of God. This God reminds us daily that we do not actually know the difference between right and wrong, not matter how powerfully we assert it, that we are not good, ever, not matter how certain we feel, that we must have a faith which knows only one good, only one God.

Sister Margaret faced a truth that we must face every day, though hopefully in not such a dramatic way. Life is full of choices too large for human beings.

We cannot depend on them. We must only depend on Him.

For our own safety, for the sake of our mortal souls, maybe we should stop trying to be right so much, and be thankful for the God who saves us in spite of them, from them, and through them.

Sister Margaret, our prayers are with you, and our pews are open for you.

If loving Grace is wrong, I don't want to be right ...

The only thing worse than being wrong is being right

Sister Margaret McBride can probably speak to this issue better than I.

A member of the ethics committee of St Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center, she consented along with other Doctors and professionals to allow an abortion because a patient’s life was endangered by continuing the pregnancy.

For that she has received the harshest of penalties – excommunication from her church - because of that choice. Only someone who has “married” themself to the church can fully appreciate what this has cost her.

Bishop Thomas J. Olmsted said that "the direct killing of an unborn child is always immoral." He is absolutely right of course. Sister Margaret did something wrong, and the church is unquestionably right to reprove her.

I myself cannot imagine the horror of facing such a choice – trading a woman’s life for her child’s (assuming that the baby could have been saved, which is not certain). It is an appropriate outcome in such cases, according to Bishop Olmsted, that the mother should die. To which there is also a certain horrible but inescapable logic.

Doing the right thing is not always easy. And this is what should happen in a world ruled by anyt sense of what is right, undeniably, irrevocably, and always right.

Who cannot appreciate the desire, even the need to live in such a world, with clear-cut rules and orders and categories. It is our constant search, our constant debate. And as long as we never face such choices as Sister Margaret, it seems an appropriate and fine way to live.

But then again.

Consider the ranging battles in the church today, the driving desire for the right, to erase wrong, to stand clearly on the side of God and His Word and stem the rising liberal erosion of value, of rightness. Is it not true that the Bible clearly tells us homosexuality is sinful, and if so, are we not obligated to stand firmly against it, in defense of marriage and pulpit? Churches are bleeding members and congregations for the lack of this simple rule: there is no place in the church for tolerating gay and lesbian marriage or ministry. None.

And shouldn’t then this always be our modus operandi? If we are called to the place about right and wrong then we will stand with integrity and power over and against all manner of sinfulness, wherever it is clearly proclaimed by Scripture and Tradition. We shall eradicate our pews of adulterers and fornicators, of liars and cheaters, of the irreligious and the intemperate.

People who forsake the speed limit on the freeway. Students who cheat on tests at school. Employees who take pens or post-it notes home from the office. Pastors who look at their Facebook page during office hours.

Do you know where this ends? I do. With Sister Margaret McBride and her awful, unimaginable, choice. Divorced from the church we love and the God we need.

Though it seems at first blush not to be, the fact is that Bishop Olmsted surely had a choice, too. What he did in excommunicating Sister Margaret was affirm the Law of God, the primacy of righteousness, and the authority of the church. What he did was turn his back of Jesus Christ.

For the sake of being right he forsook grace.

And we live daily in danger of doing so, too.

Someone recently reminded me that there are many, many people in the church who are angry and frustrated, who fear the direction of the church in its unwillingness to stand correctly against things that must be wrong. Someone recently reminded me that to many people this doesn’t seem like their church anymore.

Which it is not. Nor has it ever been. This is the church of Jesus Christ, who rules his kingdom in a very different way.

Being right is a powerful anchor, a steady foundation in the stormy seas of a difficult and confusing world. But like all weights, it is also the force that holds us down, turns us against one another, keeps us from rising above the real powers of sin, death and the devil, restrains us from the very Grace of God. Being right is the power to drown our church, each other, ourselves. Being right is very death.

It was Luther, finally, who reminded us, that the gift of Grace is a more wonderful “daily drowning” in baptism, the collapse of our search for righteousness until all that remains is a healthy dependence of the Grace of God. This God reminds us daily that we do not actually know the difference between right and wrong, not matter how powerfully we assert it, that we are not good, ever, not matter how certain we feel, that we must have a faith which knows only one good, only one God.

Sister Margaret faced a truth that we must face every day, though hopefully in not such a dramatic way. Life is full of choices too large for human beings.

We cannot depend on them. We must only depend on Him.

For our own safety, for the sake of our mortal souls, maybe we should stop trying to be right so much, and be thankful for the God who saves us in spite of them, from them, and through them.

Sister Margaret, our prayers are with you, and our pews are open for you.

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

The new face of book banning in the 21st Century





When I was young, the hard work of removing books from school libraries and curricula was focused mostly on books with an overly developed sexuality, lest they needlessly stir up simmering adolescent hormones. Which was a fairly significant challenge in and of itself.

Classic book burners went after writers with radical social outlooks, agitators, communists all. But that was then and this is now. Having lost the battle against ideas, I guess it’s time to go after the scientists.

A local school district is being pressured by a few parents to remove the dangerous tome The Down-to-Earth Guide to Global Warming and its companion video because it dares to present carbon-pollution-driven global climate change as science, even as scientific fact, when everyone knows “scientists disagree.”

Now, is that “scientists” who disagree, or just oil and coal company lobbyists? And is it truly actual disagreement, or just nit-picking over data and detail? I’m skeptical of the skeptics.

That this protest is being made by the wife of a Congressman who has voted for the oil companies and against clean energy legislation is probably noteworthy, but oversimplifies this conversation.

Then again, when has it ever been simple? What are the forces, not of nature but of human power and corruption, that have always stood against the pursuit of knowledge, that have disputed fact when it challenged institution, that persecuted Copernicus and Galileo, that shunned and still shun Darwin? When has the world ever accepted as truth proven fact when it was difficult or costly so to do? The answer is mostly never, especially when such truth calls out the sin and stupidity and corruption of the powers that rule us and the way we’ve always done things.

Undoubtedly, the real danger of Laurie David’s book is her portrayal of the “big corporations” who are accumulating untold wealth at the expense of the environment. One ought not expect such powerful giants to stand idly by, or not pour their considerable resources into the work of contesting this smear to their reputation. Luckily for them, they own plenty of Congressmen and Congressmen’s wives to aid their cause.

But Ms. Terry is right about one thing. The oil companies are not the enemy here. At least not the only one. We are. It is our dependence on cheap energy, our addiction to the road of least resistance, our unwillingness to change our habits and give up our indulgences that pollutes the earth. Oil is pouring into the Gulf of Mexico because we desire it, we demand it. Tarred beaches and destroyed marine life are the inevitable outcome of the battle for cheap gas in my SUV.

We are willing to bear the consequences of using oil because we are unwilling to do the hard and expensive work of converting to clean energy and changing the way we live. Whatever happens to the environment in the meantime, well, that’s a problem for some other day, some other generation.

All of which points to the greater and even more indisputable truth which has little to do with science. The despoiling of our plant, of God’s planet, is a serious moral failure, a great sin, a human catastrophe. Challenging the science is a great distraction, a way to not face up to the significant crimes we have been and are still committing every day against ourselves and generations to come. We have failed as human creatures, and we are bearing now the cost of our wrongdoing.

It must stop.

Congressman and Mrs. Terry, we should communicate that to 6th graders and 60 year olds in whatever way, by whatever book or video, we can.

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Fences


As the Macondo oil spill haunts the gulf coast of America, one man proposes a giant sand bar that would keep the pollution away from shore and protect sensitive environments like wetlands, beaches and casinos. Dredging, I understand, could begin in 10 days.

It may be a workable solution, a good idea. It may help minimize the impact of a significant environmental disaster. And it is the perfect human reaction.

When faced with any calamity, with any hard problem, we build a fence. We build a wall, a border, a defense. It is the predictable and inevitable jerk of the knee final resort to any of the real or scary bogeymen that inhabit the universe. Build a fence.

Crime? Add a security system. Computer predator? Get a network firewall. Immigration problems? Build a border fence. Protect what we have. Protect us. From them.

This is the thinking, the acting, that makes us human. And this is what condemns us to the lives we live.

It was St. Agustine who coined the phrase incurvatus in se – curved in on ourselves – to describe the state of living in sin. Our brokenness is this intransigence for defining life by how the world affects me, hurts me, harms me, scares me. That “how this affects me” is the smallest part of any problem in the world is of no concern. It is, from beginning to end, all we consider, all we see.

Never mind that this is what inflames the madness of our world. Never mind that the denial of our own culpability in the problems that trouble us condemns us to suffer them again and again. Never mind that seeing our own needs and not our own truth is our daily and final death.

No, just build another fence.

Or maybe there is another way.

Faith calls us to a powerful and new vision of life that reaches beyond fences to causes, to the root issues and needs and solutions that make the world out there less threatening, less harmful. Faith turns our attention from self to other, from today to tomorrow, from what is to what might be. Faith sees blessings not as treasures to be protected but gifts to use to transform the world and every life in it.

Faith turns us back to a God who breaks free from the tomb and invites us on the same path.

You see, the problem is that there is no fence high enough or wide enough or strong enough to protect us from all that threatens us. There is no border fence that will keep out every immigrant who want to, who needs to come in. There is no structure that can keep every drop of oil off from coast or wildlife, either this spill or the next one. There is no alarm system that can’t be beaten by a determined thief, no computer software sophisticated enough to keep your identity sacrosanct if someone really wants it.

But there are ways to be safer. There are ways to reduce poverty and corruption in neighboring governments. There are ways to not need more oil. There are ways to create jobs and futures and optimism in American cities. Oh, they are harder, higher, difficult, but there are ways.

There are ways, but they require skills and dreams other than building fences.

They require faith. They require the courage and hopefulness to look outside of our own very small needs and face the larger and more wonderful possibilities of the world around us.

They requires us to know that we are not the world but we are in it.

Shall we seek these ways, or shall we just build another fence?

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

We are not losing faith in the church. We never had it.

The news is filled with scandal, pain, sin. What does it mean to see the church so lost, priests molesting children, superiors secreting them in their brokenness, passing along suffering in place of healing, corruption abounding? For many, the news about the Roman church is another chapter in the neverending story of human perversion, greed and dishonesty. But an important, perhaps the important story, is muted beneath the hubub about sexual orientation and clerical marriage. Like all things of this world, outrage and disgust conceal the deeper and more important truths, the fine meaning behind acts and events and words that change lives, that changes the world.

For while much will be spoken and written over sinful priests in the church, little will be said about the real captivity of Rome, the imprisonment to a simple but enduring word: Infallibility.

Infallibility is the belief system that multiplies tragedy into catastrophe; turns shortsightedness into blindness. It is the simplest, meanest, most popular and destructive mistake in all of human thinking. It runs the world.

It runs the world away from God.

From its birth, the Roman church has founded itself on such a principle, on the belief that the Lord endowed his disciple Peter with particular powers, ordained in his successors. It is what makes the Roman church the Roman church, the absolute trust in the God-granted authority of its words and deeds, and of the men who speak and make them.

To be infallible is to be trustworthy in classic Catholic theology. It influences and locates the laity of the church, it colors and shapes every doctrine, teaching and act of the priesthood.

It is the church’s great blindness.

Infallibility means that the work of God cannot be done by an ordinary human being, and so contrives to transfer divinity to a place where it can never fully reside. Infallibility is a system built on a lie which produces nothing but wrong.

For the sake of fairness, let us know that infallibility is not the sole provenance of the Roman church. It dwells wherever men place final significance in fixed things. It’s consequence is inanity, cruelty, death. Infallibility confuses the text with the truth, leading people to believe, for example, absurdities like humans living with dinosaurs, as if the Flintstones was a Discovery Channel special and not an after-school cartoon. Infallibility confuses lust with love, destroying families and communities. Infallibility confuses free market principles with greed at all cost, breeding obscene wealth and decadent poverty, loss of justice and economic disaster.

And so it goes. Confusing humans with saints preserves a system that cannot bear the truth, until it casts off victims and coddles criminals.

But the true loss is not merely of the world. It is the loss of faith.

Grace draws its power from very fallibility. It is the real brokenness of this world, the humanness of person and text and shortcoming and even sin that breathes life into God’s promise, the resurrects sinners, that infuses days with joy, that incarnates hope. God does not send grace to remove humanity, but to renew it. Faith calls us to trust solely and completely this one promise, in his promise and not our own, to walk always humbly and fearfully of what we could do, dependent on what he will do.

Grace is a promise that comes to fallible people.


But when Jesus heard this, he said, “Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick. Go and learn what this means, ‘I desire mercy, not sacrifice.’ For I have come to call not the righteous but sinners.”

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

that April 20 could be a New National Holiday

It is not an anniversary worth celebrating.

Waco. Columbine. Oklahoma City. A group calling themselves “Hutaree” is in jail in Michigan, or there would probably be another ignominious name to add to the list this year. A day more of infamy than anything else, and if not for the sorrows of many victims, it would be a day well worth forgetting.

Which is why it is an anniversary worth remembering.

Anger is the most underappreciated of all human phenomenon. St. Paul says “Be angry, but do not sin.” (Ephesians 4:26). Of course, he also thinks that wives should follow their husbands and husbands should love their wives like Christ loves us, so his objectivity is questionable, to say the least. In fact, a few verses later, he suggests that we just “put away … all bitterness and wrath and anger and wrangling and slander, together with all malice, and be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving …” (Ephesians 4:31-2). As if he heard what he was actually saying and thought better of it, too.

A prominent TV commentator says that God has called him to stand, “peacefully, quietly, with anger.” With what? Anger? How does that work? It’s far too clever by half, as my Grandpa used to say. Most of the angry people I see are neither peaceful nor quiet. They are everything but. Since when did peaceful and angry decide to not be opposites anymore? I didn’t get that memo. What new dictionary are we reading today? Or is there something else afoot? Should we now declare anger a Godly aspiration? Do we need more anger?

No, we have far too much anger I think.

Anger is a tool. A dangerous tool. Fear is the great motivator for otherwise ignorant masses, and anger is fear with an outward bend, fear in search of a scapegoat, of release. Anger provides the convenience of an enemy, a deception that salves failure with violence, replaces hope with passion, and explodes on the lives of the other for the preservation of the lowest, basest part of me. Manipulated by fear, cast down on my anger, I am Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, I am Tim McVeigh.

In the hands of the devil, anger is the crucifixion of Christ all over again.

But in the hands of another? Oh!

Anger could be a different tool. Anger bent introspectively is humility, self-awareness, perhaps even change. Anger felt in truth, about truth, fashioned by truth, refines, distills and purifies life, it clarifies judgment, propels determination.

And that anger is in much short supply.

Perhaps we could enshrine a National Day of a new anger and ritualize a new truth – that we are the force of destruction and death that we fear most, that we are the enemy of our freedom and well-being. Perhaps a new national holiday of anger could be used to attack the foes that deserve our anger, the poverty, despair, pain and greed that are sucking the life out of our community.

A day of a new anger, directed not at the end of what is so much as driving us to the hard work of what ought to be.

Imagine capturing the energy of all of our hatred and building something instead of blowing it up, nurturing life instead of taking it, finding and taking new paths instead of burying each other on old ones. Picture a righteous anger that is not conceived in falsehood nor which leads not to sin, but a sacrificial anger, a cleansing anger, a fragrant offering of an anger. Imagine if we saw the world as it truly is, as God sees it, a world birthed and renewed and spirited in love. Can we know the distance between what we are doing and what we have been called to do?

Maybe if we were angry enough we could do something about it.

And that would be an anniversary worth celebrating.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Playground Bullies and Nuclear Treaties


“The United States is declaring that we will not use or threaten to use nuclear weapons against non-nuclear weapons states that are party to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty and in compliance with their nuclear nonproliferation obligations.” (President Barack Obama)

And the response?

"It's kinda like getting out there on a playground, a bunch of kids, getting ready to fight, and one of the kids saying, "Go ahead, punch me in the face and I'm not going to retaliate. Go ahead and do what you want with me." (prominent politician and celebrity)

OK, I get that. I grew up on that schoolyard, I know that inherent violence of this world and the need to stand up for oneself.

It is, in fact, central to the American mythos, this emphasis on strength, on confidence, on self-reliance. The great American dream is to stand up victoriously to the neighborhood bully, to look him in the eye without backing down, to protect our own best interest without flinching.

It is this aspiration which has kept us safe and free for generations.

I can understand it. I can even honor it. I just can’t reconcile it with the teaching of my faith.

“But if anyone strikes you on the right cheek, turn the other also.” Matthew 5:39

It is not, lest we profess our uncertainty, just another one of those things that Jesus uttered out loud. It is not a redactor’s trick, or an invention of the institutional church grown too far from its apostolic roots. It is the very heart and nature of Christ’s teaching, ministry and mission, and that pretenders to expertise in American Christian values do not understand this is our great sin.

Christians are called to be people of peace. Of passive, even non-resistive peace. Of active, sought-out, reconciling-with-enemies peace. Of reaching out, toward, across, down, beyond, peace.

Christians are named to be followers of a Savior who holds not a sword in his hand but the mark of a nail. Of a Savior who asks us not to “conquer” but to “endure.” Of a Savior who called down not armies of angels from his cross but words of forgiveness.

Christians are called to be people of peace as students and heirs of the man of peace, not as a hobby, not as a possibility that may come after every adversary is destroyed, after all other options are exhausted, but people who love peace, hope for peace, seek peace,
live peace.

It is a tribute to our ignorance that we do not see how impossible peace is between two peoples who desire either victory or annihilation, not peace. It is a great evil that many of us (often not too secretly) are pleased to see the advance of their hatred. How amazing it is to see even the miniscule reductions of weapons, to hear conversations of any kind reflecting the possibility of less warfare. It should be celebrated, prayed for, not criticized, not scorned.

Oh, how unattainable to live a Christian life in this world! Oh how great our failure to live worthy of our Savior. Thanks be to the God of grace, who practices what he preaches, and offers us not a violent posture but the embrace of compassion, not condemnation for our helplessness, but a Spirit of peace, an opportunity for hopefulness.