Tuesday, January 24, 2012

of Trade and Justice


Records show that the giant and ground-breaking office supply company Staples added tens of thousands of jobs during its relationship with Bain Capital, the venture capital concern of which Presidential candidate Mitt Romney is now so famously associated.  He is, justifiably, proud of that result.

Which is entirely beside the point.

By which I mean to say, that it is not beside the point as a measure of either Mr. Romney’s capabilities as a capital manager nor of the Staples enterprise as a business model, but that it is entirely beside the point as a measure of capitalism as it is currently being practiced today.

For this is most certainly true: the addition of tens of thousands of jobs was neither the purpose of nor the measure of Bain Capital’s involvement with Staples.  They did not invest in the company to create jobs – they invested to increase their own wealth.  Period.  Whether Staples had grown and employed more people or not would have made no difference – they would have returned, and probably amply, on their investment, as they did in so many other similar instances.  Dade Behring medical testing returned more than 4 times an $85 million dollar investment but went bankrupt in a decade.  Stage Stores returned $100 million on a $5 million investment, as did American Pad and Paper.  Both went bankrupt, as did many others, but Bain still profited, and mightily at that. 

That is the point.

Capitalism, for all of what it may be in theory or hope, is in its current expression mostly the corrupt and greedy practice of seeking the gain of personal wealth without the burden of adding any value to the larger community.  The stock market is no longer a place to build a retirement nest egg or save for a child’s education, it is a giant casino where loathsome practices like short-selling are no longer cheating, but normative.  Corporations create stock dividends instead of goods and services that elevate our common standard of living, their executives are not properly rewarded for their hard work but blindly paid off with gluttonous compensation packages whether they succeed or fail.  Banks are not vaults of safety, protecting the hard earned savings of laborers or supporters of individuals, families and small businessmen pursuing their dreams, but corporate con men, packing their bad decisions for carefree marketplace swap meets. 

Which is only part of the point, too. 

This is not news.  For all of our idealistic pretension of freedom and opportunity and thrift and the American way, we have always known this about the marketplace.  No, it is not merely the system which is to blame, it is our willingness to unleash the beast in hopes that it will consume our enemies and, by some miraculous and impossible fate, bring in the ship of our own good fortune.  Did not Dr. Luther warn us centuries ago? 

“Among themselves the merchants have a common rule which is their chief maxim and the basis of all their sharp practices, where they say: ‘I may sell my goods as dear as I can.’ They think this is their right. Thus occasion is given for avarice, and every window and door to hell is opened.”   On Trade and Usury (LW 45:246)

In the end, it is not Capitalism that must be fettered, but us, not business that must be regulated, but us, not trade that must be ordered, but me.  Perhaps that is why we resist it so, because we see, however dimly, in the worst practices of modern business our own greed and corruption.  Capitalism is as it is because we are as we are.  We dare not confess its depravity aloud, because if it is wrong there, then it must be wrong in me, too. 

But perhaps, just perhaps, if we could bring ourselves to the hard choice, if we could find the courage to chain that great beast and tame it and bring it under yoke and turn its power to the betterment of all and not just the enrichment of a few, then we might in fact discover the possibility of realizing God’s vision of justice, even in the system of Capitalism itself.  For what the great Reformer spoke in the negative, we might see in the positive:

“Selling ought not to be an act that is entirely within your own power and discretion, without law or limit, as though you were a god and beholden to no one. Because your selling is an act performed toward your neighbor, it should rather be so governed by law and conscience that you do it without harm and injury to him.” Luther, Martin, On Trade and Usury (LW 45:248)

Perhaps never, at least on this side of the Kingdom, will we actually create a world where what is good and right and just permeate our whole life, spiritual and economic and political.  But perhaps, if we were wise enough and humble enough and brave enough, we could come closer.

Which, I think, is actually the point. 

Thursday, January 12, 2012

Envy

Mitt Romney thinks I am jealous of him. 

He’s right.

I’d like to be able to fire service companies that don’t deliver according to my standards.  I’d like to be able to fire my insurance company if they won’t pay for a procedure or test I’d like to have done or for meds I’d like to have.  I can’t.  My insurance plan came with my job, chosen for me by someone else who decided what I could afford and what I could not.  I have no real say, and I surely can’t afford to go out and buy insurance on my own, affordable care act or no. 

Not that I’d get insurance from another company anyway, what with the whole pre-existing condition and all.  And it probably wouldn’t be much cheaper either.

I’d like to change a lot of things in my life.  I’d like to pay less for groceries, but commodity traders and other assorted corporate forces keep driving prices upward because they can.  I’d like to not go bankrupt sending my children to college, in fact, I’d like to be sending them to better colleges, but I can’t.  Of course, Mitt and his friends keep telling me that college is a privilege, not a right, and not everyone should get to go there after all. 

Mitt’s right.  I’m extremely jealous of him and of lots of other people who live in a world where they can get what they want and do what they want all the time. 

The question is whether or not that’s a good thing.

I understand perfectly well that it is the nature of a free society that some people will always have more than others – more money, more power, more control.  I get that, and at some level, I’m okay with it.  People are entitled to the fruits of their labors. 

But when does inequality stop becoming an incentive for aspiration and become a barrier to justice?  For that’s the real problem – not that I am jealous of Mitt Romney, who can run for political office now because he doesn’t have to worry about paying his mortgage while I can’t because I do, but that I have absolutely no opportunity to ever reach such a place in my life, nor do the other ninety-nine percent of people like me, and especially the many people even worse-off than I am.  The issue is not that some of us are richer than others, but that the benefits of wealth – success, power, control – have become the sole property of a very few, consolidated, restricted, secure behind gated communities and obscure tax loopholes. 

It’s not that I’m jealous that you got yours, Mitt.  It’s that you’ve got mine now, too.  And in this season of being told what is destroying America, let us clearly speak this one undeniable truth: as we watch old totalitarian regimes all over the world collapse because the many who were kept from power and wealth could take it no longer, let us not fail to observe the same log in our own eye.  Wealth and prosperity are not the same things.  Separating our society into those who have much and those who have some is not the same as separating it into those who have all and those who have none.

Do not scorn my jealousy, Mr. Romney.  If you want to lead this country, fix it.    

The Lord enters into judgment with the elders and princes of his people: It is you who have devoured the vineyard; the spoil of the poor is in your houses. What do you mean by crushing my people, by grinding the face of the poor? says the Lord God of hosts. Isaiah 3:14-15

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

What ugly is

It’s pretty shocking, really, the ugly stories coming out of Penn State this week.

Well, not, actually.

How many times must we bear witness to the incredibly horrific things that people do to each other til we come to understand that it is not so much that these stories are new and unusual as it is that they are far too old and normal.  It’s not that we’re animals – we should be so lucky.  It’s that we humans.  Sinful humans.  Originally and naturally sinful humans.  Prisoners to sin humans. 

Of course, we don’t want to hear that.  If offends our carefully constructed fantasies about free will and natural virtue.  We are merely good people to whom bad things happen.  We occasionally stumble, misstep, show bad judgment, err.  But we hold on, however ineffectually, to this constant myth, that we are in our very core good, just lacking the rare métier to forestall the temptations of our lesser nature. 

For who would want to face the truth of the abyss that is the darkness of his soul?

Perhaps that is how the secondary tragedy of the Penn State story came to be.  That any human being could perpetrate such acts upon a helpless child is unimaginable, that others could witness it and turn their back is another thing entirely.  The denial intrinsic to the crimes of the other coaches and administrators is more than self-serving at an institutional, academic or programmatic level.  They were protecting more than the Penn State athletic program.  They were protecting themselves from facing the truth about all of us and what we are capable of doing. 

And this perfidy with our falsely superior self-understanding is costly.

If we dared an honest assessment of our brokenness then we might accomplish the construction of a safer world, a more diligent community, a heightened awareness of the dangers we pose to each other and a greater effort at protecting those most vulnerable around us.  If we stopped pretending to be surprised at what people might do we could possibly take some steps to stop them from doing it.  Who wouldn’t trade in a little of our fabricated freedom for one fewer molested child?

But maybe that would be too shocking to do.

Which brings me to Herman Cain, who is also shocked, shocked I tell you, that anyone would dare to accuse a fine, upstanding person such as himself of any kind of inappropriate behavior.  He is, after all, a good person, a successful church-going man of good intent and purpose, and by definition above such ugliness.  Which is the more comical, but still equivalent, experience of our misguided concept of human freedom.  Even if we accept that it can happen, we are most assuredly certain that it cannot happen to me. 

Until it does.

Which brings me to the true cost of our falsely superior self-understanding.  Not that I deny the sinfulness of others, but that I deny my own complete and total corruption and in turn, deny the price paid for that sin by my Lord and Savior.  To suggest that he died on the cross for anything less that the total depravity of human nature is the height of faithlessness.   The price of my free will fantasy is the constant crucifixion of Christ.  If I proclaim my freedom, he dies for nothing. 

But when I confess my bondage, when I admit my loss, then the full power of his gracious love overwhelms, then his ransom pays my debt in full, then I become His prisoner and His alone.  As a free agent, I am alone.  As a confessed sinner, I am His, and in grace, never alone. 

 And that’s not shocking, just amazing. 

Monday, October 24, 2011

The God of flat taxes

Given how much they talk about Jesus, you think politicians would know more about what the Bible really says!

Because there are no flat taxes in the Bible. As far as God is concerned, when it’s time to pay, the wealthy pay more and the poor pay less.

For example, in the book of Leviticus the required offering for sin is laid out in extraordinary detail. The proper sacrifice for a guilt offering is a goat, a male goat, without blemish. A costly price indeed, which a “ruler” is required to give for their sin. An “ordinary” person, however, may give a female goat. Or a sheep. Or if they cannot afford that, two turtledoves. Or two pigeons. Or even one-tenth of an ephaph of flour. Whatever.

Because God’s law knows that not all people are created equal, at least not economically speaking. And in a just society, one modeled after God’s law, it is a given that those who are poor cannot afford the same as those who are rich.

But be not mistaken – this is about much, much more than protecting the poor. Though that is an extremely high priority in God’s reign, there is this other important concern – holding those who have been blessed with worldly riches to the highest responsibility for their position.

Jesus put it this way: “From everyone to whom much has been given, much will be required; and from the one to whom much has been entrusted, even more will be demanded.” (Luke 12:48) Fair share, it turns out, means something entirely different in God’s eyes.

This saying of Jesus is a punch line to a story about an unfaithful servant who, having been left in charge while the Master was away, chose not to pay the other servants but beat them and used the Master’s money to eat and drink and be merry. It is a powerful and confrontational word to a world where the numbers of both truly poor people and truly wealthy people are both increasing, where the very few enjoy the luxuries of life while more and more and more go hungry every
day. We live in a world hurtling toward a devastating judgment, a world on the brink of self-destruction, a world that does not need an economic philosophy which asks merely the same of the rich as it does of the poor.

It is not enough that consumption taxes burden the poor more heavily than the rich, or that decreasing taxes on rich people and corporations will destroy services that the poorest people depend on. It is a question of whether or not we are willing to live up to what is expected of us - not according to our political philosophies or narrow self-interests, but the God from whom our wealth comes.

A world that reflects biblical justice must tilt toward greater responsibility on the part of those who have greater wealth. It is not that God hates wealth or wealthy people (though the Bible seems to not have much good to say about them) – it is
that God despises a world that worships the accumulation of wealth. “For
the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil. (1 Timothy 6:10) Flat tax plans exist for only one reason – to protect the interests of wealthy people against the needs of the poor.

When it’s time to pay God, when it’s time to bear the burdens of supporting the needs of the whoe community, the wealthy must pay more. It’s God’s way, after all.

Wednesday, August 17, 2011

It's not the Economy, stupid!



Ben Bernanke. Benedict
Arnold. Yeah, I get those two confused
all the time.





When I was younger (I know you hate it when I start a
sentence with those words), treason was a serious accusation, rarely made,
reserved for very particular acts that aided and abetted enemies of our
nation. Selling state secrets. Sharing sensitive information about troops,
battle plans, defense systems.





It was not a word casually tossed about as a political
label, a quick cheap shot at any convenient target.





Evidently that’s changed.





Now, people who don’t subscribe to our philosophy are
traitors, policies that we differ over are treasonous, people who don’t follow
our brand of politics are terrorists, politicians, even Presidents, who don’t
do what we think they should do are unpatriotic, don’t really love
America.





It’s not my way vs. your way. It’s my way, end of sentence. You do not have different ideas, challenging
ideas, debatable ideas. You are just bad
and I hate you.





Is there no wonder that we can’t get anything done?





How amazing our egotism, how great our pride! Have we become incapable now of allowing any
diversity so that we must destroy anyone and anything which is not just like
us? Have we become so insecure that we
must cast off civility and forgo peace to protect ourselves? Is there no room in the world anymore for
anyone who is not me?





This same violence now infects the church. Anyone who believes or practices the faith
differently must be the anti-Christ, the devil, must be cast into hell. Will it be much longer before we start
burning heretics again? There is no freedom
in our theology any longer, we have imprisoned ourselves so narrowly in our
thinking that we have no option but to destroy the community in order to
protect ourselves.





Yet Jesus broke break with Pharisee and Tax Collector
alike, he spoke with divorced women, he exemplified Samaritans in his parables,
he died for all. For all! Not with words of judgment, with condemnation
even for his killers, but with grace and hope for the whole community, and with
the sacred charge to his followers that they were to bring good news to every
end of the earth.





He could do that, you see, because he knew then what we
refuse to believe, a benevolent God, a compassionate God, a God of such
extravagant love that he could not refuse anyone, could turn against no one, a
God who’s defining trait was his amazing and overwhelming forbearance and grace.





A God who could love even creatures full of hate and deceit
like us.





And all he would ever call us is his.



Monday, July 25, 2011

You Heard It Here First

Having children really cleaned up my language.

Not that I was a big user of swear words, but it’s
amazing how quickly I learned to edit what I said on the fly. And not that I’m a prude about swearing either, but I’d rather be a good example to them, of what is appropriate to say and when it is appropriate to say it. Because with all I do not know about raising children, this one thing I do know: what they hear, they repeat, they learn, they believe, they live.


Yeah, you really have to watch what you say around children.

Which brings me to wondering what they are learning from us adults these days. How to live be nice and share and play well together, how to care about things that truly matter, how to control our worse impulses, how to hope, how to love, how to live in grace?

I think not. I think what they are seeing mostly from the adults around them these days are swear words, selfishness, corruption, greed, hatred, bigotry.

How to hate? How to hate and hate and hate until you want to kill?

Last Friday we heard on the news of a horror that most of us could never imagine, of the mass murder of innocent men, women and children in the name of religion, philosophy, politics. Not surprisingly nor humorously, some commentators immediately assumed that it was yet another Muslim terrorist attack. After all, aren’t all bad things that happen Muslim terrorist attacks? It’s not ironic how wrong they were, it’s illuminating. We need a new word in our vocabulary to describe our enemy’s worst traits when they show up in our mirror.

But of the many, many tragic elements of this story, there is no doubt in my mind what the worst is: the shooter thought he was doing a good thing. A right thing. A purposeful thing. A righteous thing.

And how did he come to that conclusion?

How does a human being come to the conclusion that the wanton murder of other human beings could ever serve any larger purpose? A more wise doctor of human behavior than I will have to describe the path of that pathology, but I do know its starting point: he heard it first from some other mouth.


Hatred is not original to human beings. Anger, prejudice, violence, these are our
original sins. But it takes another voice to direct those sinful impulses against another human being. It takes help. It takes a word that must be heard first from
without.

It takes a father to teach his children to swear.

Peter Beinart asks courageously the very important question for us all:


So let’s ask that question about the real Breivik attack: Could an anti-Muslim bigot commit a large-scale terrorist attack in the U.S.? The answer is, Absolutely, because the same anti-Muslim bigotry that influenced Breivik in Europe is widespread here …

Lots of “experts” will poo-poo his question, dismiss it, out of hand, because they are afraid of it, because they know too well its true implication. We can’t acknowledge that it could happen in America because then we will have to confess our own
responsibility, our own culpability, our own disease, our own sin. Like fathers swearing in front of their small children, we are teaching each other to hate, passing on our own smallness, validating our neighbor’s narrowness, fueling the violence that boils not far beneath the surface of our society.

The attack in Norway on Friday is not merely one man’s psychosis, it is our national (international?) personal failure. And if we do not have the ability to filter what we say, then perhaps it is time we started listening to what the person next to us is saying. Or the guy on the radio. Or the woman on the TV. Or the person on the campaign trail.

And to do something about it.



Thursday, June 9, 2011

mea culpa








for nothing is covered up that will not be uncovered, and nothing secret that will not become known. (Matthew 10:26)




Is there a right to privacy anymore?




Analysts of the most recent (of the long line of) sex scandals involving prominent elected officials find fertile ground to raise this most difficult question: is everything we do really everyone else’s business? What a Congressman does on his or her own time, however disgusting, is his or her own business, as long as it’s legal, after all.



Why should we care? Why should we even know?




It’s kind of an interesting question. Public officials are accountable for acts that affect their public office, for corruptions and crimes that degrade their official status, but does that apply to everything they do? Is the state of their marriage, their relationships, their personal peccadilloes the business of anyone but themselves?



In this age of tabloid journalism, we are besought on all sides by titillating stories of our favorite celebrities and least favorite politicians, and we are hooked. We are addicted. We are fully obsessed. The only thing more fun than reality TV is the daily soap opera that is real life itself. Now in the digital society, we can know everything about everyone, and the more lurid the detail, the greater our lust for it.




But our great enthusiasm for this distraction masks the real spiritual dilemma. While we celebrate the demolition of the privacy of others, we live in great fear for the exposure of our own. We join in the laughter at others, lest the bright light turn to our own lives.




Because here’s the dirty little secret: we all have one.




And what would we do if it became known? What would we do if the world around us, the people we care about, the ones we depend on and whose affection we seek, found out the truth about us? What would we do if the closet door sprung open and the skeletons came tumbling out, the smallness and pettiness and dirtiness of our deepest minds and hearts were shown?




And worse, what would we do if God knew how we really thought and felt and acted?



Oh …




For that is both the conviction and the freedom of our secret lives – that God really does know everything about us, every hidden sin, every expressed and unexpressed desire, every shameful weak moment. Though we would lock them deep into the abyss of our secret selves, he knows them, considers them, judges them.




And loves us still.




To be exposed to public ridicule and contempt is the greatest punishment that this world has to offer. As it should. There is a difference between right and wrong, between good and bad, even in this world. Married men should not be sending lewd and naked pictures of themselves to strange women. None of us, public nor private, should be involved in, connected to, approving of such behavior. None of us should be doing in private what we do not wish to have know in public. There does not need to be any excusing.




But there is a greater judgment than facing the TV cameras. It is the confession of the truth about us to the highest and holiest power, it is the admission of our shortcoming to our maker, that is most fearful. But it is exactly that one, who knows it all before we can speak it, before we can admit it, before we can even know it ourselves, who opens his hands in grace and loves us, not just in spite of our secrets, but because of them, who offers us a new reputation and new identity and new life for the sake of Jesus Christ.




Sin boldly, said Luther, but be even more confident in the mercy and forgiveness of God. Let go of the secret guilt and step out into the light of the new day.




There is no privacy before God, after all. There does not need to be.