He just chose the wrong words, that’s all.
That’s what he said.
I can understand that.
As someone who makes a living with words, I’ve used the wrong ones
plenty of times with a range of negative consequences, too. I’ve been imprecise, unclear, even misleading
at times. I’ve tried to be too clever
for my own good. I even said “alleluia”
out loud once on Ash Wednesday. OK, I
haven’t lost any national advertising sponsors, but that’s probably just a
reflection of the differences in our stations in the world.
No, I can totally understand using the wrong words.
Except that’s not the problem.
He may say he wishes now that he had been more
circumspect in his choice of epitaphs, a little less racy (without losing his
signature edge) and a little less open to the onrush of criticism and shame
that came his way. He may say he wishes
now that he could have made his point and still provoked the expected emotional
response from his target audience with a bit less rage and indignation from his
foes. But regardless of what words he
chose, he intention was unmistakably the same.
He absolutely meant to insult Ms. Fluke, to attack her personally, to
slur her standing as a way to degrade her opinion.
It wasn’t wrong words, but bad intentions that caused
this melee.
Which is what really matters.
The over-personalization of our public conversation has
moved past digging up old skeletons to outright name-calling. We don’t even have to know anything about our
opponents now to attack them, in the absence of an argument against their ideas
we can just let go and take a personal shot or two. A couple of well-placed four letter words and
some prurient imagery is not just allowable – it’s the norm for free discourse
in American life today.
The new default position is disparagement before
deliberation, defamation before discussion.
Attack politics get better ratings, after all. Unless you use the wrong words and chase away
all of your advertisers.
But there is, as you should know, a better way.
“We should not betray, slander, or defame our neighbor,
but should apologize for him, speak well of him, and interpret charitably all
that he does.” (Small Catechism) So says the father of the Protestant
faith. What a dramatic change that might
bring to our national conversation. How
much more productive we could be if we could stop acting like a bunch of fourth
graders on the playground at recess and like, though it’s almost unimaginable
at this point, adults.
Even Christian adults!
Luther’s words, ironically, restrain me from further
criticism on this topic, lest I lose my entire morning as I am compelled to
confession. I can merely say that I hope
that they could suggest a better path forward for somebody.
For all of us.

