In 1974, the Catholic Church said, “Man may never obey a
law which is in itself immoral.”
Acting on that teaching, in 2004 Vatican officials
encouraged US Catholic Bishops and Priests to refuse Holy Communion to then
Presidential candidate John Kerry for his refusal to support anti-abortion
legislation.
This week, commenting on Republican Congressman Paul
Ryan’s budget proposals, the US Conference of Bishops of the Roman Catholic
Church said that because the budget disproportionately cuts programs that
“serve poor and vulnerable people,” it does not meet “moral criteria.”
Will Roman Catholic Bishops and Priests now assume their
sacred duty to excommunicate the author of this immoral budget (also Catholic) or
any of its supporters?
I doubt it.
This is, of course, the problem you get into when the
church dabbles in politics.
You find yourself in bed with politicians who are willing
to stand with you on certain issues which are morally significant, like abortion
and homosexuality, only to watch them take abominable positions on a whole host
of others issues like social and economic justice, war and torture, the death
penalty, care for the creation. You look
across the aisle and find the rest of the church on the other side, in the same
predicament, married to politicians who constantly let them down, and you
realize that you’ve become pawns in someone else’s game of divide and conquer.
And you want to speak, but this act of hypocrisy has silenced
the prophets. Ignorant, partly at your
own hand, your flock has turned their back on much of the Scriptures, only to
support political positions that crucify Jesus over and over again. And the worst part, the absolute worst part,
is that the throng of outsiders watching this farce sees, knows, how
indefensible and untenable your place in the world has become. And they hate you for it.
And then it really hits you.
This is not a political failure. This is a spiritual one.
Because this is the problem that you get into when the
church refuses to preach grace.
Convinced that our worldly works and human actions
determine our place in heaven, saying but not trusting fully the truth that it
is the work of Christ alone which saves us, the church has confined itself to
the role of Worldly Moral Police, following the winding path to a place from
which it can no longer speak truth to anyone.
The work of politics is, after all, the consummate human endeavor, awash
in violence and greed and self-indulgence and bigotry, a veritable cornucopia
of sin. It is most surely no place for
the church of Jesus Christ.
Most assuredly, yes, the political world is desperately in
need of the church’s voice, of our most prophetic word, of our critical eye and
our spiritual guidance. But the church cannot
speak to the problem when the church is the problem. The church cannot free those in prison when
it has put itself into the same chains.
The church must always, constantly and powerfully distinguish itself
from the world it if is to help the world at all.
The church must be grace.
Grace, after all, is not that which comes from
within. No, grace is the word that comes
from without, the voice of God spoken from beyond us, the voice come from
salvation to those trapped in sin. The
voice of grace is not a voice of this world, it is a voice of a God come into
the world, come to lead his pilgrim people to the next world.
A church sold out to the politics of this world cannot be
grace, cannot speak grace, cannot save.
Is this the time when the church divorces itself from its
unholy marriage to worldly politics?
Unfortunately, I doubt that, too.




