In the true spirit of “the Priesthood of all Believers,” the President entered the theological fray during his commencement address at Notre Dame last weekend. He posits an interesting thought:
The ultimate irony of faith is that it necessarily admits doubt. It is the belief in things not seen. It is beyond our capacity as human beings to know with certainty what God has planned for us or what He asks of us, and those of us who believe must trust that His wisdom is greater than our own. This doubt should not push us away from our faith. But it should humble us. It should temper our passions, and cause us to be wary of self-righteousness.
This comment was a precursor, of course, to the President’s exhortation to a humbler, gentler discourse on topics of all kinds and in particular the one over which he found himself at odds with so much of his audience. But it also gets to the heart of matters, which is probably why he drew criticism. Michael Sean Winters says, “it is not doubt that invites humility. It is faith itself …” Pardon the pun, but from a purely empirical point of view, Winters’ point seems doubtful to me.
I see people every day who are doubtless and assured in their faith. They are on my Television and Radio and they pen strongly worded diatribes in my local newspaper and on the internet. They gather at places like Westboro Baptist church and are so absolutely certain of their dogma that they hardly blink as they consign their neighbors to eternal damnation. They wave and shout and cry in the pews, impressed at the dynamic power of their faith. They have humility, yes, the certain and confident humility that they have chosen wisely in their faith, they are awed by that to which they belong and don’t understand why I’m not awed as well.
But I also meet people who have a different kind of faith, a courageous faith that sees bluntly the works of this world and the dark thoughts of their hearts and trembles at the implausibility of their salvation. They carry thoroughly searched and worn out Bibles, and they pray quietly crumpled in their pews, not sure if they belong in the presence of such a God, but desperately hopeful that they might end up there regardless. Doubt is their assurance – there is nowhere else to turn.
Paul Tillich wrote in Dynamics of Faith that “serious doubt is confirmation of faith. It indicates the seriousness of the concern …” For faith to be humbling, it must be overwhelming, far above us, beyond understanding and even beyond belief. It is that God who merits trust and worship, and it is that God who rewards meekness each time we open our mouths. We speak of what we do not know because we must. It is the miracle of the Gospel.
Which is where, with all due respect, the President and his critics are mistaken. The question of faith becomes necessarily misdirected when it becomes a question of our faith. But the Gospel reminds us that faith itself is the gift of the resurrection, that every self-endeavor dies on the cross, that all human striving, with or without doubt is insufficient. “I believe that I cannot by my own faith or effort believe in my Lord Jesus Christ or come to him …”
Winters asserts confidently that, “there is nothing ironic about faith.” Really? I find it amazingly ironic to glorify an ancient symbol of torture and death, to feast on a bit of bread and wine and dare to call them body and blood, to pray to the very creator of all and be promised that he counts even the hairs on my head. Ironic? Please. More like ridiculous. Foolish. Unbelievable.
For Jews demand signs and Greeks desire wisdom, but we proclaim Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and foolishness to Gentiles, but to those who are the called, both Jews and Greeks, Christ the power of God and the wisdom of God. 1 Corinthians 1:22-24
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
Thursday, May 14, 2009
a spring parable

In spring comes my nemesis.
They look innocent enough, to be sure, small golden wisps floating innocently to the warm spring earth. But, oh, how they float. By the thousands they come, a blizzard of debris that layers the ground with promises of yardwork, dirty fingernails and sore backs.
They are of course seeds, these falling helicopters from my wonderful maple tree, God’s clever plan to procreate acer saccharinum from generation to generation. And they are clever bits of biological engineering, wafting gently to the waiting ground, their slender fins atwirl, ensuring that they nose to the earth in such a way as to maximize their opportunity to find a fertile place waiting and stretch out their roots and make life.
One wonders about the farmer who sows his seeds so indiscriminately. For each that finds worthy ground, thousands end on roof and sidewalk. They fall millions by millions, but how many, really, might ever fulfill their purpose? One, or two? A handful at most. Small outcome for such great hope.
And as he sowed, some seed fell on the path, and the birds came and ate it up. Other seed fell on rocky ground, where it did not have much soil, and it sprang up quickly, since it had no depth of soil. And when the sun rose, it was scorched; and since it had no root, it withered away. Other seed fell among thorns, and the thorns grew up and choked it, and it yielded no grain. (Mark 4:4-7)
Too often we view life as such a mistake. It falls all around us and we treat it as so much litter. It is in our way. It is not pleasing by our standards. It does not fit into our landscape. We cannot perceive its higher purpose, so we disregard both its creative source and its creative aspiration. It is too easy to dehumanize the other, to devalue and dispose. It is as if we despise it.
But even more so, we fear it. It overwhelms us, this promise of Grace. For God is the sower in this parable, casting seeds far and wide in some unknown but insistent plan. This is the unseen value of life, that it comes so abundantly, so madly. Where it seems only one or two seeds might do, God sends millions. Where we might plant more cautiously, God sows everywhere. Each seed carries in it a divine purpose. Each has hope.
So when we take up violence so easily, when we casually label enemy and terrorist, when we justify torture and murder, we mock the creator, the untamed sower, the giver of life. When we are miserly with our regard for others, we are immoral and we reap unto such judgment. We neglect the divine nature, that each life is the same, that each is valuable as the next, that we all fall from the same place to the same earth and in the divine grace we are one.
That is his secret. The divine plan escapes us, but we cannot escape it. We are all part of it, wherever we land. That we would have such grace for others would be a fruitful work indeed.
Other seed fell into good soil and brought forth grain, growing up and increasing and yielding thirty and sixty and a hundredfold.” Mark 4:8
They look innocent enough, to be sure, small golden wisps floating innocently to the warm spring earth. But, oh, how they float. By the thousands they come, a blizzard of debris that layers the ground with promises of yardwork, dirty fingernails and sore backs.
They are of course seeds, these falling helicopters from my wonderful maple tree, God’s clever plan to procreate acer saccharinum from generation to generation. And they are clever bits of biological engineering, wafting gently to the waiting ground, their slender fins atwirl, ensuring that they nose to the earth in such a way as to maximize their opportunity to find a fertile place waiting and stretch out their roots and make life.
One wonders about the farmer who sows his seeds so indiscriminately. For each that finds worthy ground, thousands end on roof and sidewalk. They fall millions by millions, but how many, really, might ever fulfill their purpose? One, or two? A handful at most. Small outcome for such great hope.
And as he sowed, some seed fell on the path, and the birds came and ate it up. Other seed fell on rocky ground, where it did not have much soil, and it sprang up quickly, since it had no depth of soil. And when the sun rose, it was scorched; and since it had no root, it withered away. Other seed fell among thorns, and the thorns grew up and choked it, and it yielded no grain. (Mark 4:4-7)
Too often we view life as such a mistake. It falls all around us and we treat it as so much litter. It is in our way. It is not pleasing by our standards. It does not fit into our landscape. We cannot perceive its higher purpose, so we disregard both its creative source and its creative aspiration. It is too easy to dehumanize the other, to devalue and dispose. It is as if we despise it.
But even more so, we fear it. It overwhelms us, this promise of Grace. For God is the sower in this parable, casting seeds far and wide in some unknown but insistent plan. This is the unseen value of life, that it comes so abundantly, so madly. Where it seems only one or two seeds might do, God sends millions. Where we might plant more cautiously, God sows everywhere. Each seed carries in it a divine purpose. Each has hope.
So when we take up violence so easily, when we casually label enemy and terrorist, when we justify torture and murder, we mock the creator, the untamed sower, the giver of life. When we are miserly with our regard for others, we are immoral and we reap unto such judgment. We neglect the divine nature, that each life is the same, that each is valuable as the next, that we all fall from the same place to the same earth and in the divine grace we are one.
That is his secret. The divine plan escapes us, but we cannot escape it. We are all part of it, wherever we land. That we would have such grace for others would be a fruitful work indeed.
Other seed fell into good soil and brought forth grain, growing up and increasing and yielding thirty and sixty and a hundredfold.” Mark 4:8
Thursday, April 23, 2009
Persistence of remembering

I’ve been haunted by Salvador Dali’s melting clocks, the vision of time passing as fading, dying, dripping slowly away into seeming nothingness. No end, no conclusion, no resolution, but intermindable useless death. Time, or maybe life, seems to be such, without hope or presence or meaning. Just an ethereal wisp, a foggy blanket, an unknown prison.
I wonder this on a week after Easter. There was this one day, this family reunion of a gathering, old unseen friends suddenly reappearing, recommuning, recommitting. Full congregations of well dressed smiling faces and children in bonnets and shined little boy shoes. We are all the church again, hail, we are here, and the meaning and purpose of this place is resurrected with Jesus, the stones of complacency and busyness and distance rolled away and life be praised.
But then a few days past, and the pews again vacated almost as quickly as the tomb. And now time again drips surrealy by, the days long and drawn slowly forward. I wonder, in the empty quiet of the church, if their experience is the same, if the days pass for them in slow motion, in a distant memory of a place they used to know but now only remember like an old faded picture, a worn and broken trinket of a happiness which may or may not have happened, as they return to what they imagine is real life but fear may only be the other.
There tugs at us a memory of a person we used to be, were meant to be, were once a part of if only in the most remote corner of evolution. If only we could reconnect to that memory, only rewrite ourselves into the story, then there might come to us again a realization of the promise of us. But rather we slip silently under and fade into our lives, death coming not in a moment or an end but slowly, surely, unwittingly, bleakly.
But there is a persistence to Grace, too, a quiet not-quite-real tug at consciences and hearts that is more real than us, and cell by cell and bit by bit and memory by memory it drags us ever-complaining forth. Easter comes in passion and high drama, but the rest of the work of resurrection is slow, sure, holy work. We are becoming what we are, as death fades blackly from us there is revealed the truth underneath.
I wonder this on a week after Easter. There was this one day, this family reunion of a gathering, old unseen friends suddenly reappearing, recommuning, recommitting. Full congregations of well dressed smiling faces and children in bonnets and shined little boy shoes. We are all the church again, hail, we are here, and the meaning and purpose of this place is resurrected with Jesus, the stones of complacency and busyness and distance rolled away and life be praised.
But then a few days past, and the pews again vacated almost as quickly as the tomb. And now time again drips surrealy by, the days long and drawn slowly forward. I wonder, in the empty quiet of the church, if their experience is the same, if the days pass for them in slow motion, in a distant memory of a place they used to know but now only remember like an old faded picture, a worn and broken trinket of a happiness which may or may not have happened, as they return to what they imagine is real life but fear may only be the other.
There tugs at us a memory of a person we used to be, were meant to be, were once a part of if only in the most remote corner of evolution. If only we could reconnect to that memory, only rewrite ourselves into the story, then there might come to us again a realization of the promise of us. But rather we slip silently under and fade into our lives, death coming not in a moment or an end but slowly, surely, unwittingly, bleakly.
But there is a persistence to Grace, too, a quiet not-quite-real tug at consciences and hearts that is more real than us, and cell by cell and bit by bit and memory by memory it drags us ever-complaining forth. Easter comes in passion and high drama, but the rest of the work of resurrection is slow, sure, holy work. We are becoming what we are, as death fades blackly from us there is revealed the truth underneath.
"But do not ignore this one fact, beloved, that with the Lord one day is like a thousand years, and a thousand years are like one day. The Lord is not slow about his promise, as some think of slowness, but is patient with you, not wanting any to perish, but all to come to new life." II Peter 3:8-9
He persists. Alleluia, life persists.
Sunday, April 12, 2009
The surprise that wasn't there

It’s almost hard to remember now, as the boys get older, how much they really loved Easter Egg hunts when they were little. You could just see the amazement in their eyes as our backyard - which they had inhabited for countless hours - was suddenly full of these wonderful treasures! Where did they come from? But that question was mostly lost in the joy of finding more and more and more …
And then the real fun – opening the eggs up and finding all the goodies – candy, coins, toys. Each egg seems to hold something even better than the last and the eyes grow rounder as the pile grows bigger and bigger and bigger …
The women traveling to the tomb on the first Easter Sunday had a similar, if completely opposite, experience. They knew perfectly well how things should be and what they would find and how they would feel and what they would do. And then, BANG! A barrier removed, an empty tomb, an Angel’s words, confusion, fear, wonderment, tears, and a world turned upside down. They came looking for death. But it was gone.
The best surprise is the one that’s not there!
We know what to do with things as they are, as they should be. We’ve known that since we were very young. But this Easter is a new experience, this empty-tomb-faith, this confrontation that sends us out back into the world empty-handed, with prior expectations askew and all the things we knew for sure now shattered and all we have to go on, to go with, finally, is the drama and magic of faith itself.
This is not candy or money or toys. It is much better. It is life. It is nothing that was, and everything that could be. Go. The tomb is empty. Death is over. Go.
And then the real fun – opening the eggs up and finding all the goodies – candy, coins, toys. Each egg seems to hold something even better than the last and the eyes grow rounder as the pile grows bigger and bigger and bigger …
The women traveling to the tomb on the first Easter Sunday had a similar, if completely opposite, experience. They knew perfectly well how things should be and what they would find and how they would feel and what they would do. And then, BANG! A barrier removed, an empty tomb, an Angel’s words, confusion, fear, wonderment, tears, and a world turned upside down. They came looking for death. But it was gone.
The best surprise is the one that’s not there!
We know what to do with things as they are, as they should be. We’ve known that since we were very young. But this Easter is a new experience, this empty-tomb-faith, this confrontation that sends us out back into the world empty-handed, with prior expectations askew and all the things we knew for sure now shattered and all we have to go on, to go with, finally, is the drama and magic of faith itself.
This is not candy or money or toys. It is much better. It is life. It is nothing that was, and everything that could be. Go. The tomb is empty. Death is over. Go.
Thursday, April 9, 2009
The church is dead. Long live the church!
Just in time for our annual Good Friday observance, Newsweek writes up the 2009 American Religious Identification Survey and prophesies the death of Christianity in America. To be sure, the numbers are frightening. Self-identified Christians are decreasing as a portion of the population, the number of people who claim no affiliation with religion has nearly doubled in the last two decades.
I say, “Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord!” (Romans 7:25)
Now, I agree, the problem is real. If anything, it is understated. Even among the vast majority of Americans who claim the Christian name, there is an ever declining population of regular church-goers and committed servants. Secreted beneath the glittering appeal of immense mega-churches is the unspoken family secret of thousands upon thousands of dying churches in small towns and city neighborhoods. And even among the remnant that clings to the church are a quiet many who have given up in spirit but not in name, who still sit in the pews, going through the motions of devotion, hardly moved and barely incarnate in the Spirit.
But I say that the problem in American is not the death of Christianity. It is the death of the church.
And it may be just in time.
I don’t accept that souls have changed, that humans have dramatically evolved into some new form of being in these last generations. Our innate desire to seek the divine, to find the elusive qualities of hope and grace and joy beyond the confines of this world is the same now as it was the first time our earliest ancestors stood on two legs and gazed at the stars above. The human need for faith transcends time and technology and cannot be delineated in National surveys. Those who believe least in the church in America voted the most in the last election for – wait for it – hope. We will always chafe against death and evil and always quest for their end. There will always be a Savior because there will always need to be.
But the church – she is a human and worldly thing, and her frailties and her sins are easily diagnosed and her days are always marked. Though her blessing and mission is to be the instrument by which God’s Word is channeled unto our striving, she is to many a hindrance to faith. The harder the church seeks to matter in the world, to sit among the powerful and share their influence, to use the channels of politics and law to advance her work, the more she becomes of the world. And the more the church becomes a part of this world the less she becomes of God, until finally God’s Word is mute and the church dies. And so she has.
That is what this survey and many others like it are telling us. The church of this age has failed. We have come to a new Babylonian Captivity, to borrow a phrase from Dr. Luther. The church has come to covet the role of the Pharisees and Chief Priests in the Passion drama, far too captivated by the sturm und drang of the blood and death of Good Friday to ever make it to Easter. In her legalisms and grasping for power, the church has closed the doors of the kingdom to those few, fervent believers who associate with her narrow dogma and so has driven away masses of the lost, of those seeking something greater, something more life-giving, you know, grace.
The church is dead. Long live the church!
We are brought to Good Friday to see God’s work in its purest form: the death of what cannot be for the sake of what must be. The cross is not just a horror picture to bring us to our knees in guilt and trepidation for some approaching day of Judgment. This is a saving work, a breaking down of broken and sinful human forms and human institutions so that something right may take their place. This is the great mystery of God, that every seed must fall to the earth and die, so that it might bear much fruit.
And so the promise beckons us. Easter is coming! Somewhere, beneath the facade of the church of this world is the hidden reality of grace. Like an Easter Egg well placed, it evades our first glance and calls us to seek in diligence and faithfulness. Even as the church passes from this form, God is fashioning a new creation, a new being, a new instrument of Grace and salvation and calling the faithful to His work. I do not write these words because I hate the church – no, I love the church. I pray that it may once again rise and become again God’s Word of Redemption in the world, that we may leave our anger and judgment and worldly lust for power in the tomb behind us and come out into the world where we are desperately needed.
Let this be the Easter that the church rises again. Hallelujah!
I say, “Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord!” (Romans 7:25)
Now, I agree, the problem is real. If anything, it is understated. Even among the vast majority of Americans who claim the Christian name, there is an ever declining population of regular church-goers and committed servants. Secreted beneath the glittering appeal of immense mega-churches is the unspoken family secret of thousands upon thousands of dying churches in small towns and city neighborhoods. And even among the remnant that clings to the church are a quiet many who have given up in spirit but not in name, who still sit in the pews, going through the motions of devotion, hardly moved and barely incarnate in the Spirit.
But I say that the problem in American is not the death of Christianity. It is the death of the church.
And it may be just in time.
I don’t accept that souls have changed, that humans have dramatically evolved into some new form of being in these last generations. Our innate desire to seek the divine, to find the elusive qualities of hope and grace and joy beyond the confines of this world is the same now as it was the first time our earliest ancestors stood on two legs and gazed at the stars above. The human need for faith transcends time and technology and cannot be delineated in National surveys. Those who believe least in the church in America voted the most in the last election for – wait for it – hope. We will always chafe against death and evil and always quest for their end. There will always be a Savior because there will always need to be.
But the church – she is a human and worldly thing, and her frailties and her sins are easily diagnosed and her days are always marked. Though her blessing and mission is to be the instrument by which God’s Word is channeled unto our striving, she is to many a hindrance to faith. The harder the church seeks to matter in the world, to sit among the powerful and share their influence, to use the channels of politics and law to advance her work, the more she becomes of the world. And the more the church becomes a part of this world the less she becomes of God, until finally God’s Word is mute and the church dies. And so she has.
That is what this survey and many others like it are telling us. The church of this age has failed. We have come to a new Babylonian Captivity, to borrow a phrase from Dr. Luther. The church has come to covet the role of the Pharisees and Chief Priests in the Passion drama, far too captivated by the sturm und drang of the blood and death of Good Friday to ever make it to Easter. In her legalisms and grasping for power, the church has closed the doors of the kingdom to those few, fervent believers who associate with her narrow dogma and so has driven away masses of the lost, of those seeking something greater, something more life-giving, you know, grace.
The church is dead. Long live the church!
We are brought to Good Friday to see God’s work in its purest form: the death of what cannot be for the sake of what must be. The cross is not just a horror picture to bring us to our knees in guilt and trepidation for some approaching day of Judgment. This is a saving work, a breaking down of broken and sinful human forms and human institutions so that something right may take their place. This is the great mystery of God, that every seed must fall to the earth and die, so that it might bear much fruit.
And so the promise beckons us. Easter is coming! Somewhere, beneath the facade of the church of this world is the hidden reality of grace. Like an Easter Egg well placed, it evades our first glance and calls us to seek in diligence and faithfulness. Even as the church passes from this form, God is fashioning a new creation, a new being, a new instrument of Grace and salvation and calling the faithful to His work. I do not write these words because I hate the church – no, I love the church. I pray that it may once again rise and become again God’s Word of Redemption in the world, that we may leave our anger and judgment and worldly lust for power in the tomb behind us and come out into the world where we are desperately needed.
Let this be the Easter that the church rises again. Hallelujah!
Tuesday, April 7, 2009
Giving what is due
Since I deigned to brag that my NCAA bracket was ahead of the President, it only seems right to acknowledge that he did, in fact, correctly pick North Carolina to win it all. I'm also imagining that Coach K may opt to breakfast on a little humble pie himself this morning. "Let the same mind be in you that was in Christ Jesus, who, though he was in the form of God, did not regard equality with God as something to be exploited, but humbled himself ... " (Philippians 2:5-6)
Sunday, April 5, 2009
Looking for an opening
Thomas, who was called the Twin, said to his fellow disciples, “Let us also go, that we may die with him.” John 11:16
In the midst of all the festivities and observances of Holy Week, it’s easy to miss the other major event that comes with the arrival of April: Opening Day! (Perhaps you have the opposite experience.) And not to confuse the two, or even to equate them, but there is a striking similarity.
Finally.
That’s the feeling, after a long cold winter, after desperately following the Hot Stove League and imagining its impact on your favorite team, after long weeks of Spring Training and feverishly examining previously unknown and unheralded rookies, the day comes. Your own home team, in your own home park, bring on the hot dogs and the nachos and the cold beer (not quite so important in chilly April) and let’s PLAY BALL!
I wonder if Jerusalem felt the same way. Three long years of signs and miracles and preaching all around the countryside, in small hamlets and outlying places without names, growing in fame and reputation, but when, WHEN, will Jesus deign to step into the great city herself? That, as much as anything, might be the motivation behind the thronging crowds and the Hosannas and waving palms. Finally, he has come!
Palm Sunday is mostly a day that we observe as an end, or at least as the beginning of the end, the climax of horror and blood and death. But it is for Jesus a day of arrival, an entry, an opening. It is his way into Jerusalem and his way into us, and, as such, a beginning of victory and triumph, of life and life everlasting and abundant. The cross hides the mysteries of Heaven itself, this week is not merely the end of a long Lent but the beginning of a new life, the opening day to what will surely be our best season ever.
Yes, we have finally come, not to our end but to our opening, to the heavens opened up, the gate of eternity visible in death, mercy and divine grace shown in the very human misery of the cross. Prepare to see the stone rolled away, the tomb gaping open, prepare to hear angels bidding us who wait to live, and … let’s PLAY BALL!
In the midst of all the festivities and observances of Holy Week, it’s easy to miss the other major event that comes with the arrival of April: Opening Day! (Perhaps you have the opposite experience.) And not to confuse the two, or even to equate them, but there is a striking similarity.
Finally.
That’s the feeling, after a long cold winter, after desperately following the Hot Stove League and imagining its impact on your favorite team, after long weeks of Spring Training and feverishly examining previously unknown and unheralded rookies, the day comes. Your own home team, in your own home park, bring on the hot dogs and the nachos and the cold beer (not quite so important in chilly April) and let’s PLAY BALL!
I wonder if Jerusalem felt the same way. Three long years of signs and miracles and preaching all around the countryside, in small hamlets and outlying places without names, growing in fame and reputation, but when, WHEN, will Jesus deign to step into the great city herself? That, as much as anything, might be the motivation behind the thronging crowds and the Hosannas and waving palms. Finally, he has come!
Palm Sunday is mostly a day that we observe as an end, or at least as the beginning of the end, the climax of horror and blood and death. But it is for Jesus a day of arrival, an entry, an opening. It is his way into Jerusalem and his way into us, and, as such, a beginning of victory and triumph, of life and life everlasting and abundant. The cross hides the mysteries of Heaven itself, this week is not merely the end of a long Lent but the beginning of a new life, the opening day to what will surely be our best season ever.
Yes, we have finally come, not to our end but to our opening, to the heavens opened up, the gate of eternity visible in death, mercy and divine grace shown in the very human misery of the cross. Prepare to see the stone rolled away, the tomb gaping open, prepare to hear angels bidding us who wait to live, and … let’s PLAY BALL!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)