Monday, April 2, 2012

Five Words for Holy Week: King


The week begins with a clear agenda:  this is going to be about power. 

“Tell the daughter of Zion, Look, your king is coming to you …” begins the writer of Matthew.  The reference to Solomon is unmistakable, just as only one emerged from the royal battle for David’s throne then, so now comes only one to claim boldly that same throne, to set himself apart from throngs who desire to rule, to put down the poseurs and usurpers alike.   

He does not just want to be King, he is King, and he will countenance no other Kings before him. 

This scene, so sweetly re-enacted in our churches on Palm Sunday with branch-waving children and songs of joy and ringing hosannas is in reality more invasion than parade, a demand of something far than attention, a tongue-in-cheek acknowledgment of how much the city has been waiting for his appearance.  Perhaps he senses the irony of the moment, perhaps he knows that the next time he travels this path it will not be riding on a donkey but dragging a heavy cross.  Perhaps he knows how these cheers will be overcome by shouts of “Crucify Him” too few days from now.   

Perhaps that just steels his will all the more. 

For this is one thing I know about Kings – they must be Kings.  Real Kings, not those who desire power but those who actually have it, do not need to threaten or bribe, coerce or plead, they do not need even to seize power by violence or subversion.  Real Kings own their crown, it is part of them, they are beholden to no one but the God who grants them their place.

Such is this King, entering the city now, waving benignly and supremely to the adoring crowds, moving forward toward his impending coronation, to the most ironic moment of them all. 

For it is in that monumental sacrifice, in the humiliation and the horror of the crucifixion, that his kingliness is truly revealed.  Not by power, not by conquering army or overwhelming might, but in his gracious act of self-giving he puts to an end all pretensions of power, every enemy, destroys sin and the devil and even death itself.  Here the name of King is redefined forever, here the absurdity of every worldly King is laid bare, here is founded the Kingdom that never ends.  

Not by gold is he crowned, but by thorns, and the blood which flows from those wounds shines brighter than any precious gem.  

Behold, O Zion, you King is coming to you. 

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Stand and Don't Fight. Please.


Now the works of the flesh are obvious: …  enmities, strife, jealousy, anger, quarrels, dissensions, factions … Galatians 5:19-20

The Goal of Retribution. 

Don’t think I had heart that one before.

In a story last night on “All Things Considered” about sentencing 14-year olds to life without the possibility of parole, the daughter of a man who had been killed by such a criminal explained why this was proper and fitting verdict.  Rehabilitation didn’t matter, nor the cruelty of the punishment, but she thought that the criminal ought to stay locked up for The Goal of Retribution. 

I must have missed the memo when the penal system’s goal was changed to retribution.

I understand that we need jails for criminals. I understand that they need to be removed from society for our safety.  I understand that justice requires some act of punishment, some penance.  I understand that it serves many important social purposes to penalize criminals.  And I even understand that they deserve it. 

But retribution?   Is that the new thing in social goals? 

If so, then we’ve finally done it.  We have institutionalized anger and hatred. 

I can surely see it.  It permeates our public conversation after all, where we seek defeat rather than debate, where disagreement can only be resolved by destruction (self- or otherwise!)  The Goal of Retribution is the perfect rule for the “us” vs. “them” world that we have created.  Enmity is not a sin, it is a necessity for survival, it is rallying cry, a fund-raising tool.

And then there’s Florida.

Not being a resident there nor an expert in that state’s legal system, I should assume that there is some logic or reason behind the “Stand and Shoot” law.  I should, but I cannot.  I was raised to believe that if you feared for your safety, you got out of the situation, preferably with some haste and purpose.  I was taught that you left law enforcement to the professionals.  I was taught that you avoided times and places where bad things can happen, that you kept a far distance from trouble.  I was certainly not taught to go looking for it.  I was taught that two wrongs did not make a right. 

But stand and shoot presumes a very different attitude, doesn’t it?  It prefers a more aggressive posture, a willingness to meet trouble with trouble, violence with violence.  It fathoms that guns are not the problem, they are the solution.  It has a goal, you know, of retribution, to get back at the criminals and the no-good types (and don’t they always look like black teenagers?) before they can do harm. 

Ah, the pre-emptive strike, you know, the world-view that gave us the wonder of the last Iraq war.  Which sure turned out well, I think. 

Giving in to the demons of our lesser nature, surrendering to the anger, hatred of our sin, is not self-protective.  It is self-destructive.  The Goal of Retribution takes into our hands what they cannot hold, should not hold, must not hold.  It moves us outside of grace and imprisons us in the violence of our own creation. 

And when we’ve shot all the teenage hoodlums, who will we shoot next? 

And what would Jesus say to that? 

I say to you, Do not resist an evildoer. But if anyone strikes you on the right cheek, turn the other also.  Matthew 5:39

Monday, March 5, 2012

Wrong Words


He just chose the wrong words, that’s all.

That’s what he said. 

I can understand that.  As someone who makes a living with words, I’ve used the wrong ones plenty of times with a range of negative consequences, too.  I’ve been imprecise, unclear, even misleading at times.  I’ve tried to be too clever for my own good.  I even said “alleluia” out loud once on Ash Wednesday.  OK, I haven’t lost any national advertising sponsors, but that’s probably just a reflection of the differences in our stations in the world. 

No, I can totally understand using the wrong words.

Except that’s not the problem.

He may say he wishes now that he had been more circumspect in his choice of epitaphs, a little less racy (without losing his signature edge) and a little less open to the onrush of criticism and shame that came his way.  He may say he wishes now that he could have made his point and still provoked the expected emotional response from his target audience with a bit less rage and indignation from his foes.  But regardless of what words he chose, he intention was unmistakably the same.  He absolutely meant to insult Ms. Fluke, to attack her personally, to slur her standing as a way to degrade her opinion. 

It wasn’t wrong words, but bad intentions that caused this melee. 

Which is what really matters.

The over-personalization of our public conversation has moved past digging up old skeletons to outright name-calling.  We don’t even have to know anything about our opponents now to attack them, in the absence of an argument against their ideas we can just let go and take a personal shot or two.  A couple of well-placed four letter words and some prurient imagery is not just allowable – it’s the norm for free discourse in American life today.

The new default position is disparagement before deliberation, defamation before discussion.

Attack politics get better ratings, after all.  Unless you use the wrong words and chase away all of your advertisers. 

But there is, as you should know, a better way. 

“We should not betray, slander, or defame our neighbor, but should apologize for him, speak well of him, and interpret charitably all that he does.”  (Small Catechism)  So says the father of the Protestant faith.  What a dramatic change that might bring to our national conversation.  How much more productive we could be if we could stop acting like a bunch of fourth graders on the playground at recess and like, though it’s almost unimaginable at this point, adults. 

Even Christian adults! 

Luther’s words, ironically, restrain me from further criticism on this topic, lest I lose my entire morning as I am compelled to confession.  I can merely say that I hope that they could suggest a better path forward for somebody. 

For all of us.

Monday, February 20, 2012

If you only knew what gone really was


The long awaited and oft-predicted epitaph of the mainline protestant church has finally been pronounced:  “It is gone from the world of Christianity as I see it.”

Not that we who labor in the church haven’t feared it for lo these many years.  In countless workshops, assemblies, continuing education seminars and coffee table (or tavern booth) conversations we have held forth greatly on the declining attendance, resources, relevance and spiritual well-being of our ecclesiastical fraternity.  We have known since before we received our ordination the difficulties that we faced, the challenges set upon us and the certain struggles that we would suffer.  Yet we willingly, even gladly undertook the mantle of leading the church of our childhood because we trusted those who had bequeathed it to us and we hoped, however humbly, that our faithfulness to the centuries of their work and wisdom would be looked upon graciously by our God. 

What a waste that was. 

In vain hope we have studied management books and hired praise team leaders and learned new worship songs and re-written our liturgies and redecorated our narthex to breathe life into our churches.  In vain hope we have sent out postcards and created visitor packets and led evangelism campaigns and invited our co-workers to worship services and spaghetti dinners and youth group outings. 

But it was all for naught, because it turns out that we are not Christians at all. 

No, it turns out that loving our neighbor, striving for justice and working towards the good of the poor, oppressed and downtrodden, seeking peace and offering our cheeks instead of our fists to those who would do us violence, preaching God’s word in its fullness and not merely its most convenient parts, practicing the ancient sacraments and rites of the community of believers was actually the problem.  Was wrong this whole time.  Turns out that we weren’t even close on what it means to be Christian at all.  All those things we read in the Bible, all those lectures from our seminary teachers, all those lessons from our beloved Sunday School teachers were wrong.  Turns out that being a Christian is really at once simpler and more perfunctory than we have ever imagined or practiced it to be. 

And now we are blessed, finally, with a true prophet, who in one brief and sweeping Christian fatwa has undone centuries of evidently misguided church workers and freed us from the prison of our fruitless efforts.  We are not Christian, we are no longer welcome in the church, we are helplessly lost, pagan, worthless. 

Whew.

I, for one am thankful.  Perhaps I will begin my retirement now, before the rigors of Lent, the sorrows of Gethsemane, the humbling of Good Friday.  Perhaps I will forgo the vain proclamation of what God has done for his people in Christ Jesus and get busy at stopping the “the corruption of decency” so evident in the NBA, rock concerts and movie sets.

Or perhaps, as I endure one last Ash Wednesday, I will hear anew these words of St. Paul, “We are treated as impostors, and yet are true; as unknown, and yet are well known; as dying, and see—we are alive!”  (II Corinthians 6:9) and I will remember that it is not for one politician to decide who is Christian or not. 

That job lies entirely in the hands of another, hands marked by nails driven by Pharisees old and new, hands I will trust solely for my eternal well-being. 

Let the journey begin …

Sunday, February 12, 2012

Sometimes the Catholic Church can be a real pill


“All worldly things are placed under the dominion and power of the church.”  Unum Sanctum (Giles of Rome, 1302)

It seems we haven’t come very far these past 710 years. 

Once upon a time Popes crowned Emperors.  Once upon a time, Bishops ruled territories, collected taxes, made laws, executed civic justice in the name of the God whose vestments they festooned.  Once upon a time the political served the behest of the clerical, the corruption of worldly power infesting Prince and Pope equally, indistinguishably.  Once upon a time both church and government failed because neither knew their place. 

But once upon a time (as I read history) a German monk and his reforming colleagues broke the shackles of a world imprisoned by the theocracy of the totalitarian church, separating the spiritual from the political, empowering each to own individual, unique, distinct place and purpose.  We consider this newly birthed understanding an enlightenment, for it brought in the modern age, made possible modern democracy and modern government and modern people.   

Today we describe the Islamist tendencies and Jihadist atrocities of our Muslim brethren as a barbarism that we long ago abandoned, a knee-jerk rejection of a society that cannot be rejected, a less-than-quaint antiquity of a desire to subdue people with religious tyranny that we have long since learned is wrong and cannot function.  We think it wrong in their aspiration and practice. 

So why should it be ok in ours?

The unmistakable subtext at work in the description of insurance coverage for contraception as an assault on religion exudes the musty odor of a longing for those good ‘ole medieval days when  Pope spoke and Emperor did, when the church’s word was the world’s law, binding, unquestioned good.  Dominionism, even for those who deny the nomenclature, is bubbling up in 2012 in a strange alignment of protestant and catholic believers who decry the strangulation of personal liberty at the hand of government but favor of the denial of freedom at the hand of the church. 

Forget for one moment the creation destroying and justice annihilating implications of the church’s denial of contraception or the theologically pregnant equation of fertility with justification.  Overlook Catholic institutions that already provide insurance plans to their employees, Catholic or otherwise, which include contraception. Disregard that almost all Catholics in this country in fact use contraception. Accept the right of the Roman Catholic or any other church to dictate their religious belief to their followers in whatever way they choose with whatever means are at their disposal. 

Remember, instead, that the Catholic church, like the Lutheran Church or the Evangelical Church or the Mormon church is in this time and place a church, surely and merely a spiritual body residing in the midst of a very non-spiritual kingdom, where we are all called by the God who created both church and government to function as creatures of this world, who calls us to submit ourselves to the law of this kingdom even as we live by the grace won for us in Christ’s. 

“For anyone who desires to reside in a city is bound to know and observe the laws under whose protection he lives, no matter whether he is a believer or, at heart, a scoundrel or knave.”  (Martin Luther, Introduction to the Small Catechism)

Asking the church to respect the laws of the land in which it resides and works is not waging war on the church.  Not letting the church dictate what laws it will follow or what laws it will not is not waging war on religion.  No, pretending to be victimized by the big bad government is just a clever, but disingenuous way to hide the age-old desire of the church to rule over it.  No one is asking believers, Catholic or otherwise, to practice contraception if they find it against their faith.  But it is right, necessary and good to ask the institution of the church, a citizen of the world, to know its place and let the government govern. 

“Render unto Caesar the things that are Caesars,” said Jesus. 
 
Keep your faith.  Practice it well.  But let the church be the church.  And let the government do its job. 

Thursday, February 2, 2012

A Hard Word to a Cold World


They were lined up waiting for us. 

Politely, to be sure, patiently even.  Standing in the cold (and thank heavens it wasn’t a truly cold night as a January night should have been) with minimal coats and few, if any, hats or gloves.  Waiting for the arrival of a spoonful of warm, if not particularly tasteful food, a few slices of bread and a couple of ounces of juice. 

They were lined up waiting for not much.  But it was all they had to wait for.

The real face of American poverty, standing in a deserted parking lot on a cold dark evening is a stark reminder that we are not all living in the same country.  For many, for too many, for far too many of our neighbors and fellow citizens, poverty is not a statistical anomaly or a poor economic outcome, it is a daily disaster, a personal struggle for survival, an unsecured free fall.  For those few folks on that one January evening, waiting for a bite to eat before they shuffled back to their substandard housing or the car they lived in or the steam grate they slept over, it’s something to be actually worried about.

Mitt Romney, candidate to lead all of the people of this nation and be caretaker for its soul, did not, as many commentators, make a political gaffe this week.  He promulgated our great national lie; that poverty is just a minor inconvenience that affects a small portion of the population who are kept fat and lazy by overdone government largesse and a vast and effective network of religious, charitable and beneficent persons and organizations. 

It’s a lie – not because there isn’t help, but because help is not a good enough answer to the real truth of poverty in America.

Fifteen percent of Americans, or 46 million human beings, men, women and children, live in poverty right now.  That means absolutely that they do not have enough money for food, clothing and shelter, certainly not at the same time.  More so, thirty percent of us live within the reach of poverty, perhaps having just enough money for the most minimal needs.  Yes, those have TV’s, but they don’t have reliable transportation, or health care, or money to send their children to college.  And sixty percent of Americans, the experts say, live within one missed paycheck, one unaffordable medical disaster, of increasing the ranks of the most poor among us. 

No, Mr. Romney, the poor are not fine, they are not kept by the so-called “safety net,” which at its worst, prolongs their suffering and never, even at its best, changes their circumstances.  No, they are not just a few percent of surplus population (to borrow the phrase from another well-known Scrooge) who can be disregarded for the sake of some more important political demographic. 

Actually, I am not worried about the poor, either.  I am scared to death for them. 

As long as we live in a country where care for the least among us is treated as a hobby, a diversion for those needing occasional penance or the few who can afford the luxury of feigned, sometime interest, the empty stomachs and the long lines waiting for a warm meal will grow only longer and longer.  Until it becomes our national responsibility, our common calling, then we will share together the guilt and the savage price of the poor among us. 

A wise man wrote some 500 years ago:  “Nobody ought to go begging among Christians. It would even be a very simple matter to make a law to the effect that every city should look after its own poor, if only we had the courage and the intention to do so.”   (Martin Luther, a Letter to the Christian Nobility).

Our apologies, Dr. Luther, for our failure to hear your word, and for our continual selfish willingness to tell ourselves lies in the face of our Lord’s sacred charge.

They are still lined up, waiting for us. 

Tuesday, January 24, 2012

of Trade and Justice


Records show that the giant and ground-breaking office supply company Staples added tens of thousands of jobs during its relationship with Bain Capital, the venture capital concern of which Presidential candidate Mitt Romney is now so famously associated.  He is, justifiably, proud of that result.

Which is entirely beside the point.

By which I mean to say, that it is not beside the point as a measure of either Mr. Romney’s capabilities as a capital manager nor of the Staples enterprise as a business model, but that it is entirely beside the point as a measure of capitalism as it is currently being practiced today.

For this is most certainly true: the addition of tens of thousands of jobs was neither the purpose of nor the measure of Bain Capital’s involvement with Staples.  They did not invest in the company to create jobs – they invested to increase their own wealth.  Period.  Whether Staples had grown and employed more people or not would have made no difference – they would have returned, and probably amply, on their investment, as they did in so many other similar instances.  Dade Behring medical testing returned more than 4 times an $85 million dollar investment but went bankrupt in a decade.  Stage Stores returned $100 million on a $5 million investment, as did American Pad and Paper.  Both went bankrupt, as did many others, but Bain still profited, and mightily at that. 

That is the point.

Capitalism, for all of what it may be in theory or hope, is in its current expression mostly the corrupt and greedy practice of seeking the gain of personal wealth without the burden of adding any value to the larger community.  The stock market is no longer a place to build a retirement nest egg or save for a child’s education, it is a giant casino where loathsome practices like short-selling are no longer cheating, but normative.  Corporations create stock dividends instead of goods and services that elevate our common standard of living, their executives are not properly rewarded for their hard work but blindly paid off with gluttonous compensation packages whether they succeed or fail.  Banks are not vaults of safety, protecting the hard earned savings of laborers or supporters of individuals, families and small businessmen pursuing their dreams, but corporate con men, packing their bad decisions for carefree marketplace swap meets. 

Which is only part of the point, too. 

This is not news.  For all of our idealistic pretension of freedom and opportunity and thrift and the American way, we have always known this about the marketplace.  No, it is not merely the system which is to blame, it is our willingness to unleash the beast in hopes that it will consume our enemies and, by some miraculous and impossible fate, bring in the ship of our own good fortune.  Did not Dr. Luther warn us centuries ago? 

“Among themselves the merchants have a common rule which is their chief maxim and the basis of all their sharp practices, where they say: ‘I may sell my goods as dear as I can.’ They think this is their right. Thus occasion is given for avarice, and every window and door to hell is opened.”   On Trade and Usury (LW 45:246)

In the end, it is not Capitalism that must be fettered, but us, not business that must be regulated, but us, not trade that must be ordered, but me.  Perhaps that is why we resist it so, because we see, however dimly, in the worst practices of modern business our own greed and corruption.  Capitalism is as it is because we are as we are.  We dare not confess its depravity aloud, because if it is wrong there, then it must be wrong in me, too. 

But perhaps, just perhaps, if we could bring ourselves to the hard choice, if we could find the courage to chain that great beast and tame it and bring it under yoke and turn its power to the betterment of all and not just the enrichment of a few, then we might in fact discover the possibility of realizing God’s vision of justice, even in the system of Capitalism itself.  For what the great Reformer spoke in the negative, we might see in the positive:

“Selling ought not to be an act that is entirely within your own power and discretion, without law or limit, as though you were a god and beholden to no one. Because your selling is an act performed toward your neighbor, it should rather be so governed by law and conscience that you do it without harm and injury to him.” Luther, Martin, On Trade and Usury (LW 45:248)

Perhaps never, at least on this side of the Kingdom, will we actually create a world where what is good and right and just permeate our whole life, spiritual and economic and political.  But perhaps, if we were wise enough and humble enough and brave enough, we could come closer.

Which, I think, is actually the point.