Wednesday, June 15, 2016

The Uncertain Gospel

This week, in the aftermath of yet one more mass killing in our country, a Pastor in Sacramento California shared his own particular experience of sorrow.  “The tragedy,” he said, “is that more of them didn’t die. The tragedy is I’m kind of upset he didn’t finish the job – because these people are predators. They are abusers."

Them being the homosexuals who frequented the Pulse club.  Them being an abomination before God according to Leviticus and therefore worthy of such a fate (if not worse.)

Evidently this Pastor was sad that he couldn’t shoot them himself. 

Which is more shocking – that a Pastor would speak such words at this time, or that he would speak them at all?  Or is it that these are not merely random words of hatred and anger, but that they are words bred at the heart of the struggle for faith in the church?

After all, Leviticus has been with us for a long time.  We all know what it says.  And we all know what it means, don’t we?

Or have we just been wrong all this time?

Pastor Jimenez’s comments, spoken especially at this time, confront us like a mirror held too closely to the face and call us to self-reflection.  We recoil at the callousness, the selfishness.  We rebuke this thinking – “this is not what we believe!”  We do not wish any part of such an agenda, yet we cannot so easily repudiate the role of these words in our history and in our tradition.  Shall we just deny the sacred writings of the faith?  The Bible is a whole, not a collection of interchangeable and conveniently dismissible parts.  Shall we just flee from the church and leave this struggle behind?  Many, too many, have already made that choice.

No.  We would be just as lost as them.

If only there was another option.

I believe there is, though I confess to not knowing it fully.  I am convinced, however, that it starts with humility, a kind of humility that has become much lacking and greatly absent in the church of this age.  It starts with the almost impossible question:  what if we’re wrong?

I was not trained to ask such a question in my seminary education.  I was not trained to ask such a question in years of Sunday School and Confirmation.  No, I was raised in the certainty of faith, in the surety of the presence of God and the certain work of his holy church.  Faith was definable, knowable, determinative.  The church was a mighty fortress, built on doctrine and dogma, sacred practice and holy Word.  Even the spiritual was concrete.  It was what it seemed to be, what it was said to be, forever and ever, world without end Amen. 

And so it has become our prison. 

The problem for me is that being horrified by this kind of hatred and small-mindedness is not enough.  I am still a product of and a responsible party to the Word of God, the whole of the Scripture, the long tradition of my church and the heart of its people.  I am tied to that, I am anchored to that.  I cannot simply walk away.  I must be set free from it.  Set free by a power much, much greater than I. 

If we are to break from this confinement, if we are to find the path between overly self-righteous loathing and hatred and aimless, meaningless futile wandering, then we must begin not with what we know but with what we do not.  Before we can come to the revelation that comes from God alone, we must put an end to the revelations that come from ourselves.  We must end so that faith – true faith! – can live.

And to fully make that move, we must become uncertain.

I know this to be a risky proposition.  It is much easier to stay where we have always stood (at least where we think we have always stood – that is a different matter entirely).  It is easier to take the short route, the shallow exegesis, the simple answer.  It is easier, but it is not right, for in taking the easy way, the simple way, the known way, we will surely come to the end we deserve.

Pastor Jimenez’s summation of the Orlando massacre was that “they deserve what they got.” 

Will we?

1 comment:

  1. I particularly like your metaphor of certainty as a prison. And I think many people are happier there.
    As educators, we understand that growth is painful. As humans, we know that growth is painful. Certainty is painless! How simple it is to say, “God said so.” The person with the key to the Bible magically gets to know what God wants. The rest of us just listen. We don’t have icky decisions: we just obey.
    Freedom, on the other hand is uncertain and scary. It is our own burden to act, or our decision to not act, and we each must answer for our choices.
    I wonder what we can do to help release people from their own insularity. One reason many Americans are more accepting of the LGBTQ community today is that so many of us have begun to understand that this community includes our own friends and relatives – who are each as God-like and God-beloved as any of us pretend to be - just as when we come to know people of other races and faiths, we (hopefully) discover our common humanity. It is so much more gratifying to grow together rather than apart, but how can we encourage people to embrace the complex unknown, instead of simple certitude?

    ReplyDelete