Tuesday, July 26, 2016

Authority


Us Christians look for revelations in the strangest of places.  We seek truth while we pray in our closets, or from Michael W Smith lyrics, or from obscure passages in Jewish wisdom literature.

And sometimes we miss out on really important things that are right in front of us.

I got revelation just this week, and I got it from the strangest place.  In the middle of a American political party convention.  No, it didn’t come from a politician or a TV commentator or a journalist.  It came from a random delegate.  And it was not meant to be revelatory.  But it was.

After the speeches were over Monday evening, a TV reporter asked a die-hard Bernie Sanders supporter and millennial for her reaction to his speech and who she was going to support going forward, especially given the contentious divisions in their party. 

“I believe anything Bernie says.  He is the one politician I have heard that I absolutely believe.”

“Bernie told you tonight to vote for Hillary Clinton.”

“Well, I don’t believe that.”

And there you have it.  Everything you need to know – not about politics – about the social and historical forces pulling apart the church’s mission in this generation.  It may well be the ultimate question for the church going forward (as Phyllis Tickle has noted).  Where is the authority?

The church’s work has always been about authority.  The truth of our doctrine, the veracity of our teachings, the power of our message stem from their authority, depend on authority.  We are not making one argument among others, we are speaking truth, eternal and immutable truth.  And the authority from which we speak must be indisputable.

That authority is not just us!  It comes to us from without, from beyond, from above.  Whether it was the apostles, the Emperor, the pope, the Priest assigning penance or the Pastor preaching the gospel, the denominational leader or the TV celebrity, authority has always been external.  My willingness to submit to that authority is necessarily dependent on my ability to trust it, to understand it, to willingly submit to it.  Which is not always easy or given.  How do I know these authorities are trustworthy?  What if they are wrong?

Even the scriptures themselves are an external authority.  They are words speaking across a span of time and distance and generations and society, but they are external to me.  And so they suffer the same weakness of all external authority.  Trying to read the Bible literally reveals it to be archaic, internally inconsistent, factually wrong.  Trying to read it metaphorically tempts us to reductionism and escapism.  Since the last great reformation the Bible has been upheld as the ultimate authority of faith and doctrine and practice.  Since the last century, the Bible has been an object of criticism and doubt. 

No wonder that this generation has finally reached the end of the authority rope. 

Do not be mistaken – this is not their fault.  It is ours.  We have insisted on blind obedience to authority and they, educated, sophisticated and plugged-in as they are, have noticed that the emperor has no clothes.  We have taken the veracity and dependability our own faith for granted and assumed that everyone else would, too.  And we have been caught off guard when they refused. 

This generation is calling us to a new measure and definition of authority in the church, and even in the world.  They will no longer simply take our word as authority, but now demand that we bring them into the experience of faith, that we give them something actual and incarnate to hold to as their own.  They do not want to be told what to believe.  They do not even want to be told to believe. 

They want to believe for themselves.  They have to believe for themselves. 

Good for them.  Good for us. 

No comments:

Post a Comment