Showing posts with label grace. Show all posts
Showing posts with label grace. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 29, 2020

Community: The Problem of Me

The truth was always there in the Word: this is not about me.

Except that I keep making it about me.

It’s most visible in the way we distort theology. Luther said that the two most important words in the Institution of the Holy Communion are “for you,” but we have twisted it to make ourselves the subject of the sentence and not the object. The common Christian creed, “Jesus died for my sake” is not given to build up my ego. As humans are gifted to do, we have converted the love of God for the whole cosmos into our own personal spiritual nest egg. Get it? Personal.

Behold the mantra of Americanized Christianity! Jesus is my “Personal Savior.” My choice. Jesus exists because I believe he does. Jesus matters because I say he does. I determine the extent and the depth of our relationship; he answers when I call but otherwise keeps out of sight. I may subject myself to a particular teaching or praxis in the same way I might choose Coca-cola over Pepsi – I am perfectly loyal until something better comes along. But in all things I am the consumer, the chooser, the subject of faith.

No one can tell me what to do.

Because I have free will. I make choices everyday about everything, including faith. Reinforced by consumer culture, free will is the great canon of modernity: “I choose, therefore I am,” to paraphrase the foundational philosophy of the age. If it is so in my head, if it is so in my experience, then it must be so in all things. We determine who we are and how we are to be. Who would want it to be any different?

It does seem reasonable. Our days are filled with choices large and small. It is what we do most, if not best. Religion demands choices too, a constant examination of deeds, an awareness of what is good and what is not and a never-ending navigation between the two. We choose to go to church or not, to pray or not, to observe the appointed rites and days or not. We choose what words to say, how to spend our time and energy, what cause to support, how to treat one another. Choices seem to be a good thing – they lend order to the world and purpose to our lives.

Except not all choices are the same.

Choices, like all things human, have limits. They reside within the reach and scope of our own being, and no more. We want to believe that our choices have consequence, even eternal consequence, not just for the moment or for the foreseeable time, but for all time. We walk through life certain of our ability to manipulate others, influence history, and in the end, sway the very mind of God. He is the great heavenly bookkeeper after all, noting our good works and keeping track of our falls. So by definition he is at the mercy of what we choose to do. He may be the God of all things, but I have free will.

In other words, he is the god of nothing.

Free will is the self-indulgence that corrupts faith. Luther’s great debate with the budding humanism of his day remains a primary challenge for the faith community of the twenty-first century. Our faith in free will colors all we think, believe and do. It is not merely a doctrine that beguiles our proclamation, it is foundation of what we believe and profess, independent of scripture or reason or effect. And that is the problem. Suddenly all of the praying and the teaching and the praising and the serving becomes a slave of one thing: me.

Free Will is the great conundrum of religion. We believe in a God who sets strict commandments (which are pretty much impossible to fully keep) yet is powerless to do anything except condemn his creation to eternal punishment. We believe in a Savior who sacrificed everything for us but depends on our devotion to give his death significance or meaning. We throw around titles like “Lord” and “King” as if they were merely abstractions, indulgences. In truth we only truly submit to Masters of our own choosing, limiting their power within the boundaries of our allegiance. Unless we acknowledge God, preferably publicly, unless we choose to proclaim God’s lordship, God has no immediate consequence. God’s love may be unconditional, but salvation is not. We are very glad to have Jesus as our partner in this journey we call life, but in the end we drive the bus.

God loves us, but in and of itself, grace ultimately changes nothing.

And there it is. This is how the assumption of free will runs contrary to faith, to the core reality of what we actually believe. Jesus died for us. Not merely because of us, but the gospel proclaims that his suffering, death and resurrection does a transformative work in us and in the world. The cross is not a metaphor or archetype to persuade us into a particular theological stance or lifestyle choice. It is an act of grace that changes everything. That changes me.

Isn’t that the true reason we hold on to the myth of free will? Deep down we do not want to change. We want to believe in something, we want to be a part of something, but we are looking for a belief system and a lifestyle that affirms our own choices. We want causes that touch our own heart, requirements that fit our schedule, words that are affirming and ministry that is comforting. We believe that religion should be self-sustaining in every sense of the word, and the American Christian Church of the 21st century has embraced and embodied that idea and made it our national creed. The constant division and re-division of the church into increasingly smaller denominations was not because of theological squabbling. It was the product of millions of free wills asserting themselves over and over against anyone who dared to preach the gospel.

The communion of the saints has not merely been divided. It has been rejected.

Now we come to a moment where the character of our faith is tested. The pandemic and our ongoing social struggle are uncovering our brokenness and now we are called to a different faith. We were not saved from the world for ourselves, we are saved from ourselves for the world. Incurvatus in se, as the great reformer would say. The more we keep turning back in toward ourselves, the more desperately we cling to free will, the farther we are removed from God, Jesus, salvation, purpose. We think ourselves powerful. CoVid-19 and Black Lives Matter have revealed the truth: we are not capable, we are culpable.

That has to change.

So why do we insist on asserting our free will?

Maybe it’s a control thing. Maybe it’s how free will feeds our sense of ego. Despite the façade of humility we present to the world, self-love is the default mode of humanity. Or maybe it’s because we love to win. Religion, like pretty everything else in society, has become a competition. My church is bigger than your church. My righteousness is bigger than your righteousness. My soul is better than your soul.

Mostly I think it’s because we have disdained the demands of God on how we are actually living today, on the world we have made. We worship a God who is in charge of the world to come, not the world as it is right now. Our single-minded imprisonment of religion to matters of life-after-death unshackles us from any obligation to the present. Creatures of free will, we are liberated from anyone who would dare to tell us what to do or when to do it. Religion is the ultimate pyramid scheme – we are all on the lookout for our next great opportunity to procure a proper place in the hereafter. We just have to make the right choice, and everything will be fine.

Except we never make that choice, do we? We establish elaborate systems to define righteousness which are mostly about someone else, about choices that do not actually affect me. We focus morality in the narrowest of terms (usually sex) and ignore the great weight of the Word that decries the lack of justice and peace in the world. We are modern incarnations of the kingdoms who persecuted the prophets, who enjoyed their wealth and comfort and neglected widows, orphans and strangers.

What shall we make of this illusion of choice? What if the Holy Spirit is stirring in 2020, trying to tell us something about ourselves, about our choices? Perhaps if we could let go of the all-consuming desire to choose our way into God’s favor we would have the time and energy to make some choices that would actually change our world and the way we live, that could bring help and wholeness. If we actually believed in the promise of our baptism we could stop worrying about ourselves and love our neighbor. Then we would be truly free.

What would we do then?


Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Of spangled vests and bubblegum music

A-B-C, easy as one-two-three …

It was a crowd favorite every Saturday afternoon at Skateland in 1970. Round and round the rink we rolled to favorites like the Jackson 5. It was, I can say without fear, a different time. Now my children roll their eyes to such silly, sweet music. They guffaw at the rhinestones and the wide lapels and the platform heels for guys. And rightly so. Sigh.

The recent passing of favored icons compels our nostalgia. Ed McMahon was more than a TV star, he was a time-keeper. Bedtime was always marked with the familiar theme music and the ubiquitous “Heeeeere’s Johny!” Farah’s red swim suit did not just propel us into puberty, it made us a generation, an age, a time. We were the first to consider it plausible that private detectives could look like supermodels, that bikinis and guns could go together, and we changed both men and women because of it.


And Michael. They will say that his greatest album came in the 80's, and will speak endlessly of the strange creature he became in his later years, but I will always remember the Jackson 5 dream I wanted to live.

And now they are gone from us, these and many more, reminding us that nothing is forever, everything passes, nothing lasts. Will we?

“For everything,” says the Teacher, “there is a season, and a time for every purpose under heaven.”

An important verse, even a great song, not just because it is of that generation, but because it is of all of them, the eternal and universal truth made for these times and for the next ones that will also surely come. All that is exists only for its time, until the next comes and what was is only memory. He is the God of ADD, never satisfied with what is, restlessly passing from season to season, from age to age, from the joy that is unto the joy yet to come.

Shall we fear this impetuous creator? By no means! Let us rather match his impatient love with our own, grateful for the moments that we are given and keen to share the next adventure. Having done great things, he is eager for the next. And rightly so. Aren’t we? For his journey is ours, marked with the signposts of our treasured memories but winding ever forward to new and wonderful places we cannot imagine.

Yes, our children will never have it as good as we did. Thanks be to God for that!

Thursday, June 4, 2009

a forgotten word


John 3:17 is the poor country cousin of Bible verses.

Everybody knows John 3:16. We’ve seen the crazy guy with the multi-colored wig at the football games with his big sign often enough to know that John 3:16 is important. Even Luther called it the gospel within the gospel. ““For God so loved the world that he gave his only Son, so that everyone who believes in him may not perish but may have eternal life.” It’s all there, everything that’s important to faith: the love of God, the sending of the Son, the end of death and the wide open door to heaven. A simple saying.

But the implications, oh, the implications. They’ll get your every time.

Which is where poor old 3:17 comes in. It is one thing to speak the tender and pleasant word of grace. It is whole other thing to be confronted directly with the full outcome of grace, to face what it really means, to be called to preach it boldly and live it wholly and allow it to change your beliefs and your actions. It seems well enough to say that God loves the world, that he gave us Jesus. But what if that actually meant something?

“Indeed, God did not send the Son into the world to condemn the world, but in order that the world might be saved through him.” After the warm and fuzzy thoughts of verse 16, it seems that this grace stuff may not be as good a deal as we had originally hoped. No condemning? None at all? Because we need judgment. Judgment gives the world order, allows it to make sense. Please, we hope, we plead, at least a little judgment, at least a little punishment, at least a little wrath. For who will hold in check the forces of evil that surround us if we take condemnation completely off of the table!

Such need for judgment surely underlies the recent events in Wichita. For what else would oblige a man to enter a church (of all places) and boldly and take a gun and end a life? Because it was deserved, one would say. Because it was just. Because it was necessary to end the other wrong, the greater wrong. Let us consider that an argument could be made for such judgment, such condemnation. Dr. Tiller was an abortion doctor, even a late-term abortion doctor. Shall we just stand idly by as such acts are committed? Are we just spectators in God’s world, or is our calling to discipleship serious?

We need judgment, do we not? Shall evil reign freely?

But it is, of course, that same zeal which turns our condemnation back upon us. If not always as dramatically, we encounter our own destruction in the judgment of others. Judgment is our festering swamp, the quicksand that oozes us toward the oblivion of our own end. We are judgment addicts, living from one condemnation fix to another. But the joke is on us, for this is the painful truth of John 3:16 – there is no judgment which can redeem this world. There is only one path to freedom, the product of grace which is the Son. It is not just a nice thing. It is the death of condemnation, and, as such, of us.

The true tragedy of Wichita sleeps beneath the horror of a cold-blooded killing in the house of God. It is the death of faith, the repudiation of grace, the denial of the consequence of salvation. Yes, there is an end to the atrocity that is abortion in our world. But it must be God’s end, it must be an end found in the same grace that brought us Christ. For God has sent us this new day, not for our condemnation, but that we might all be saved.

It says so in John 3:17. Give it a read sometime.