While most of the
world has left the church, those who have remained have taken church-ness to
new heights. There is a serious
intensity and devotion to religion today.
Our certainty is not merely a shelter against the storm of worldliness,
it is a weapon that we wield proudly and aggressively. Christianity is not our faith, it is our
brand, our position. It is our
expectation, of ourselves and of others.
The world must teach as we teach, practice as we practice, in schools
and places of employment and in the marketplace and in the halls of
government. We are not merely
evangelists, we are crusaders, exerting an activist conviction that will broker
no rejection.
Perhaps,
ironically, this is a lesson we have learned from the world. It is our love of sports, after all, that
shapes our culture, teaching us that life is a game to be won, and to be won at
all costs. Winning isn’t the everything,
it’s the only thing. In the same way
that we play at economics and politics, so now we play at religion, certain
that we are not called merely to participation in the creation, but to total
and complete victory. By a clever and
self-serving interpretation of Genesis, we have defined our place in creation
as dominant, ascendant. We are not the
creation’s servants, the world exists to serve us, to worship us. We are its god.
And in this way, the Christian church itself has become its own idol in the world. Religion is not merely a path to spirituality, it is the very object of worship and devotion, our tenets and our creeds are the bottom line we serve. The Bible we read is our Bible, not a living, breathing experience of the vastness of God’s grace throughout history that speaks to us and examines us, but a cold, dead, series of proof texts subject to our own usage and narrow purpose. Doctrine and dogma are not simply tools for teaching and organization – they are the faith itself. The church today is the church of our own creation, our best work, we take great pride in it. And we expect others to worship it, too.
We come to this
point, I believe, because our primary theology is about ourselves, our trust in
our works, in our decisions, in our choices.
We have defined the church in this most basic, human term: believing.
I made the choice to believe in this way, and because I made this
choice, it is the right choice. We
worship our own works, the regularity of our attendance, our programs, our
hymnody, our righteousness, our lifestyle, because we chose them. Here is the final Americanization of Christianity
– the ultimate adoration of the god of human will.
The role of the
human will has been a great theological debate of the Christian community from
its beginnings. The question of the
right division of labor between grace and human will has both captivated and
tortured the church’s greatest thinkers.
Paul taught first that salvation comes “as a gift,” (Romans 3:24, NRSV)
that is, entirely from the hand of God, underserved, unearned, regardless of
and prior to anything we have done or will do.
But from that beginning the church has sought rather to assert the
importance and the necessity of the human contribution to salvation, through
good works or sufficient self-recrimination for bad works. Or, at least, choice.
Free will is our
idolatry. Free will is how we judge the
world and thereby keep others at bay.
Free will is the stone and mortar with which the walls of our city are
built. And it is no stronger than that,
because it is, in the end, a human construction, only as strong as we are and
every bit as weak. That is why Martin
Luther, the great protestant reformer, spoke against this dogmatic supposition
of free will:
For my own part, I frankly confess that even if it were possible, I should not wish to have free choice given to me, or to have anything left in my own hands by which I might strive toward salvation. For, on the one hand, I should be unable to stand firm and keep hold of it amid so many adversities and perils and so many assaults of demons, seeing that even one demon is mightier, than all men, and no man at all could be saved …
Instead of
upholding its importance, Luther professed, the cross of Christ necessarily
revealed the brokenness of the human will, the truth of sin, that left to our
own devices and choices we are bound to the wrong work, the wrong
inclination. This is the definition of
sin, the self-centered worship of human will and human choice, this is what
Christ died for, so that we might recognize our own powerlessness and submit to
God’s determination instead. But such
theology has no place in a church bound by certainty. Religion is, in the end, lived out in humans
and in human works. And so we battle to
the death for our own role in God’s work, and in the process constrain his work
to the inferior place. Always. We say that grace is primary, necessary,
chief. But in the end our words and acts
express our belief that grace is helpless without the work of our own hand, our
choice, our decision, our will. God
cannot save us, after all, unless we save ourselves. God cannot save us unless we want to be
saved, mean to be saved, act to be saved.
We say it is all
about God. We act as if it is all about
us.
The world can see
this, by the way. We believe it is our
best quality, this willing desire for God, our illustrious religiosity. The world sees our public confession, our
public display. But it also knows the
truth, our private guilt, our not-so-hidden corruption and sin. The world knows that even as we tout our
faith in Jesus we live and act in ways that are contrary to his teachings. We are prideful, we turn our back on
injustice, we stand with polluters and warmongers, the violent and the
oppressors. We sing our love of grace,
forgiveness and mercy, and then pronounce judgment and condemnation on
all. The world can see the log in our
own eyes even if we cannot, and names it hypocrisy, this worship of our
self-made empty religion. The world
knows our bondage, and now awaits our destruction so that it can step in and
seek the dawn of a brand new day.


