Wednesday, July 13, 2016

Idols


While most of the world has left the church, those who have remained have taken church-ness to new heights.  There is a serious intensity and devotion to religion today.  Our certainty is not merely a shelter against the storm of worldliness, it is a weapon that we wield proudly and aggressively.  Christianity is not our faith, it is our brand, our position.  It is our expectation, of ourselves and of others.  The world must teach as we teach, practice as we practice, in schools and places of employment and in the marketplace and in the halls of government.  We are not merely evangelists, we are crusaders, exerting an activist conviction that will broker no rejection.

Perhaps, ironically, this is a lesson we have learned from the world.  It is our love of sports, after all, that shapes our culture, teaching us that life is a game to be won, and to be won at all costs.  Winning isn’t the everything, it’s the only thing.  In the same way that we play at economics and politics, so now we play at religion, certain that we are not called merely to participation in the creation, but to total and complete victory.  By a clever and self-serving interpretation of Genesis, we have defined our place in creation as dominant, ascendant.  We are not the creation’s servants, the world exists to serve us, to worship us.  We are its god.

And in this way, the Christian church itself has become its own idol in the world.  Religion is not merely a path to spirituality, it is the very object of worship and devotion, our tenets and our creeds are the bottom line we serve.  The Bible we read is our Bible, not a living, breathing experience of the vastness of God’s grace throughout history that speaks to us and examines us, but a cold, dead, series of proof texts subject to our own usage and narrow purpose.  Doctrine and dogma are not simply tools for teaching and organization – they are the faith itself.  The church today is the church of our own creation, our best work, we take great pride in it.  And we expect others to worship it, too.

We come to this point, I believe, because our primary theology is about ourselves, our trust in our works, in our decisions, in our choices.  We have defined the church in this most basic, human term:  believing.  I made the choice to believe in this way, and because I made this choice, it is the right choice.  We worship our own works, the regularity of our attendance, our programs, our hymnody, our righteousness, our lifestyle, because we chose them.  Here is the final Americanization of Christianity – the ultimate adoration of the god of human will.

The role of the human will has been a great theological debate of the Christian community from its beginnings.  The question of the right division of labor between grace and human will has both captivated and tortured the church’s greatest thinkers.   Paul taught first that salvation comes “as a gift,” (Romans 3:24, NRSV) that is, entirely from the hand of God, underserved, unearned, regardless of and prior to anything we have done or will do.  But from that beginning the church has sought rather to assert the importance and the necessity of the human contribution to salvation, through good works or sufficient self-recrimination for bad works.  Or, at least, choice.

Free will is our idolatry.  Free will is how we judge the world and thereby keep others at bay.  Free will is the stone and mortar with which the walls of our city are built.  And it is no stronger than that, because it is, in the end, a human construction, only as strong as we are and every bit as weak.  That is why Martin Luther, the great protestant reformer, spoke against this dogmatic supposition of free will: 

For my own part, I frankly confess that even if it were possible, I should not wish to have free choice given to me, or to have anything left in my own hands by which I might strive toward salvation. For, on the one hand, I should be unable to stand firm and keep hold of it amid so many adversities and perils and so many assaults of demons, seeing that even one demon is mightier, than all men, and no man at all could be saved …

Instead of upholding its importance, Luther professed, the cross of Christ necessarily revealed the brokenness of the human will, the truth of sin, that left to our own devices and choices we are bound to the wrong work, the wrong inclination.  This is the definition of sin, the self-centered worship of human will and human choice, this is what Christ died for, so that we might recognize our own powerlessness and submit to God’s determination instead.  But such theology has no place in a church bound by certainty.  Religion is, in the end, lived out in humans and in human works.  And so we battle to the death for our own role in God’s work, and in the process constrain his work to the inferior place.  Always.  We say that grace is primary, necessary, chief.  But in the end our words and acts express our belief that grace is helpless without the work of our own hand, our choice, our decision, our will.  God cannot save us, after all, unless we save ourselves.  God cannot save us unless we want to be saved, mean to be saved, act to be saved. 

We say it is all about God.  We act as if it is all about us. 

The world can see this, by the way.  We believe it is our best quality, this willing desire for God, our illustrious religiosity.  The world sees our public confession, our public display.  But it also knows the truth, our private guilt, our not-so-hidden corruption and sin.  The world knows that even as we tout our faith in Jesus we live and act in ways that are contrary to his teachings.  We are prideful, we turn our back on injustice, we stand with polluters and warmongers, the violent and the oppressors.  We sing our love of grace, forgiveness and mercy, and then pronounce judgment and condemnation on all.  The world can see the log in our own eyes even if we cannot, and names it hypocrisy, this worship of our self-made empty religion.  The world knows our bondage, and now awaits our destruction so that it can step in and seek the dawn of a brand new day.

Wednesday, July 6, 2016

Flags


It is a great holiday.

Not just because it comes in the middle of the summer, when we need a holiday really, really badly.  Not just because of the great barbecue or that you get to blow stuff up (hopefully not yourself!).  Not just because of the great march music or the speeches or the patriotic display.

Independence Day is a great holiday because it celebrates a great thing.  Independence.  The foundation of this nation and the essential component of all human society.  Independence appeals most to us because it is intrinsic to our nature, the characteristic that defines us, that makes us human.  We have the ability to rise above the tyranny of our circumstances and our environment.  We can be more than we seem to be.  We carry within ourselves the aspiration to define ourselves and the will to accomplish our dreams. 

Everything good that has been accomplished by human beings has been a produce of our independence. 

And everything bad.

Injustice, bigotry, violence –these are all products of independence, too, of our need to place self above community, of our willingness to make others suffer for our desires, of our inability to give up immediate satisfaction for long range goals or to sacrifice for greater good.  We ignore corruption and destroy the planet and go to war just because we don’t want anyone else to tell us what to do.  These are the fruits of our worship of independence, our idolatry of self to the exclusion of our corporate burden. 

But what if Independence Day was a celebration of our independence from all of that? 

Perhaps we have misunderstood the real value of freedom.  The real tyranny in life is not dependence but disconnection.  We are only ourselves, and we are our best selves, as we are a part of a larger organism.  We are never fully realized until we realize our role in society, we are never whole until we are part of the greater whole of the community we share. 

We live our lives under the influence of two competing voices.  One calls us to stand apart from the crowd, to be unique and self-sufficient, to protect our privacy at all costs and live with no obligation to another.  Another sings to us a song of belonging, of the absolute magnitude of loving and being loved, of the value of friendship and family, of the power of compassion and giving.  And which one is right?

The first is the voice of sin.  It is the voice that calls us to self-regard and greed, to rampant egoism with no thought of its impact on others.  And history is filled with the wreckage of such pursuit, with the multitudes who have been crushed by the ambitions of few, the wastelands of egregious consumption, the tears of too many who have paid the price of the successes of too few. 

Yes, it promises to lead us to enterprise and fulfillment, but this is a half-truth, a lie of omission.  For we can also find enterprise and fulfillment in relationship with others.  And the truth is that we can only find enterprise and fulfillment in relationship with others.  “It is not good for man to be alone,” is God’s first reflection at our creation.  And this is the truth that determines our destiny.  It is only when we are independent from our own selfish self-interests that we can truly be who we were made to be. 

That is independence worth a great holiday. 

Wednesday, June 29, 2016

Exits




You refused the call.

Heroic words. A rare treasure in an epic focused on the greed and violence that is human nature at its worst.  That they were spoken by a child and heaped shame on older, seemingly stronger and braver men who should have known better made them all the more poignant.  That they so succinctly bear witness to the shame of our own time makes them all the more important.

You refused the call.

They are words that speak to duty, to obligation, to the undeniable and immutable responsibilities that bind us together.  They are a stark (forgive the pun!) reminder of the allegiance that we share, all of us, to one community, one humanity.  We are not islands unto ourselves.  We are not alone, no matter the distance between us.  In this world that worships at the altar of individuality and choice, they expose of idolatry and our false religion of self above all.

Not that we care.

Is it just our nature, or is it our sin – or both – to be always the ones who refuse the call?  The word of the day this week is exit, as is leaving, as in breakage, as in the pretense of independence, the denial that we are, in fact, always in relationship to others.  The choice ostensibly made to affirm that we are entitled to our own lives, to attend to own needs and to not be dragged down by the rest.  The right to separate ourselves from the harm of others in the world.  As if such a thing could be.   

The immediate consequences of this most recent exit reveals the lie of every attempt at divorce.  We are too interconnected, too intertwined, for any to go it alone.  Our selfish acts have far-reaching consequences.  We fear how others bear us harm.  What of the hurt we do them, intended or not?  We name globalism the enemy, which is like blaming the air for the pollution that we breathe.  Humanity has always been one global shared experience.  Even if we didn’t know it.

No, what is wrong with the world is us – we made it this way; we cannot, we may not, run and hide from it.  If there is so much wrong in humanity that we should not want to be connected to others, then we are responsible to fix it, not to deny it. 

To deny it is to refuse the call.

But still we do.  And as we have felt the early rumblings of this most recent exit, so we shall feel more and more down the road.  The celebration and the pride that brought this about clangs discordantly in the heavens.  The potential for more exits of every shape and size looms over us like a cross on a hill. 

But resurrection dawns in an amazing, grace-filled truth.  There are no real exits.  There is no actual escape from each other for us.  There are no walls high enough, no distances great enough, to overcome what is the very nature of God’s good creation.  Is it not good for us to be alone, he said, and so he made us, one from the other, a whole humanity, one family, from now until the end of time.  We may attempt to our utmost ability to exit from this reality.  We may refuse the call.  It changes nothing. 

We are one.  We will always be one. 

And now we are called to live as one.  Shall we answer the call?

Wednesday, June 22, 2016

Walls

There is nothing like being away to teach you to see.  Today I was reminded of something that I've actually known for a long time:  I live in a strange place. 

Not that Nebraska is strange in a weird or dangerous way.  It's just that it's not like the rest of the world.  I know what you're saying, the rest of the world is just not like Nebraska.  But statistics tell a different truth:  Nebraskans, such as we are, are in the minority.  Probably what many of us consider to be normal is, in fact, parochial, unusual.  Most of the rest of society is living a different life in a very different world.

Which really matters.
They're has been a lot of talk these days about building walls.  Here, in the midst of this new experience, I cannot help but wonder if I may already be living behind one.

I don't think I have appreciated, for instance, how many middle aged and elderly people I live around.  I have wondered often (it's a question that Pastors ask all the time) where all the young people are.  The answer is that they're here.  They live in the city, in the big city, far from the peace and quiet and boredom where I live my days.  Why?  My life and home and place is wonderful, ideal, I think.  Everyone should want to live where and as I do.
But they don't. 

Hmmm.
No, the seemingly scarce young people are here, and in abundance, omni-present, not as occasional tourists in the world (as I too often experience them in my church) but its denizens, owners of this society, home.  They are active and enthusiastic, bustling to and fro, moving purposefully and persistently toward some expected horizon. 
They are unusual creatures, these young young people.  Like Jane Goodall, I find myself in an observant posture, trying to discern what is happening in their minds and in their lives and even making up stories about them, as if I could invent insight where none was immediately available.  I notice that they are both similar and diverse, sharing common comport and style yet also of every shape, color and conviction.  They are not intimidated by their vastness nor their individuality.  They seem to know how and when to march in concert and behave according to seemingly practical, if unwritten, norms.  They are not fazed by what I find complicated and  opaque.  They get it.  I don’t.


They are often plugged in, physically, ear buds permanently affixed.  Their world, it turns out, is not bound by its physical limitations.  They are in many places and in multiple times, functionally and mentally and spiritually.  This super-power of theirs is marvelous to see. 
But mostly I notice how happy they seem.  That makes me less so.  It would be easy to see their radically different choices, their foreign lifestyle, as threat.  Is this the evolution to come?  I’m not sure I would have a place here.  I’m not sure I would want a place here. 
And that is the real problem.  That I should reach such a summation is exactly the problem.  It may be an interesting question, but it is ultimately an unnecessary one.  A wrong one.  Maybe even a shameful one.  It is an utter reminder not just of the wall that surrounds me but of my attachment to it, of my idolatry to it.  That I cannot relate to or even endure another world beyond the walls which I have defined for myself is as good a definition of sin as I have come to lately. 
And if there is any meaning to repentance, then this must be it.  That I should turn away from the constant butting up against my own walls and find, instead, a doorway, or a bridge, or whatever such thing which might open up the possibility of a connection between worlds, between me and the others, different as they are. 
Now that would be a sight to see. 

Wednesday, June 15, 2016

The Uncertain Gospel

This week, in the aftermath of yet one more mass killing in our country, a Pastor in Sacramento California shared his own particular experience of sorrow.  “The tragedy,” he said, “is that more of them didn’t die. The tragedy is I’m kind of upset he didn’t finish the job – because these people are predators. They are abusers."

Them being the homosexuals who frequented the Pulse club.  Them being an abomination before God according to Leviticus and therefore worthy of such a fate (if not worse.)

Evidently this Pastor was sad that he couldn’t shoot them himself. 

Which is more shocking – that a Pastor would speak such words at this time, or that he would speak them at all?  Or is it that these are not merely random words of hatred and anger, but that they are words bred at the heart of the struggle for faith in the church?

After all, Leviticus has been with us for a long time.  We all know what it says.  And we all know what it means, don’t we?

Or have we just been wrong all this time?

Pastor Jimenez’s comments, spoken especially at this time, confront us like a mirror held too closely to the face and call us to self-reflection.  We recoil at the callousness, the selfishness.  We rebuke this thinking – “this is not what we believe!”  We do not wish any part of such an agenda, yet we cannot so easily repudiate the role of these words in our history and in our tradition.  Shall we just deny the sacred writings of the faith?  The Bible is a whole, not a collection of interchangeable and conveniently dismissible parts.  Shall we just flee from the church and leave this struggle behind?  Many, too many, have already made that choice.

No.  We would be just as lost as them.

If only there was another option.

I believe there is, though I confess to not knowing it fully.  I am convinced, however, that it starts with humility, a kind of humility that has become much lacking and greatly absent in the church of this age.  It starts with the almost impossible question:  what if we’re wrong?

I was not trained to ask such a question in my seminary education.  I was not trained to ask such a question in years of Sunday School and Confirmation.  No, I was raised in the certainty of faith, in the surety of the presence of God and the certain work of his holy church.  Faith was definable, knowable, determinative.  The church was a mighty fortress, built on doctrine and dogma, sacred practice and holy Word.  Even the spiritual was concrete.  It was what it seemed to be, what it was said to be, forever and ever, world without end Amen. 

And so it has become our prison. 

The problem for me is that being horrified by this kind of hatred and small-mindedness is not enough.  I am still a product of and a responsible party to the Word of God, the whole of the Scripture, the long tradition of my church and the heart of its people.  I am tied to that, I am anchored to that.  I cannot simply walk away.  I must be set free from it.  Set free by a power much, much greater than I. 

If we are to break from this confinement, if we are to find the path between overly self-righteous loathing and hatred and aimless, meaningless futile wandering, then we must begin not with what we know but with what we do not.  Before we can come to the revelation that comes from God alone, we must put an end to the revelations that come from ourselves.  We must end so that faith – true faith! – can live.

And to fully make that move, we must become uncertain.

I know this to be a risky proposition.  It is much easier to stay where we have always stood (at least where we think we have always stood – that is a different matter entirely).  It is easier to take the short route, the shallow exegesis, the simple answer.  It is easier, but it is not right, for in taking the easy way, the simple way, the known way, we will surely come to the end we deserve.

Pastor Jimenez’s summation of the Orlando massacre was that “they deserve what they got.” 

Will we?

Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Swing State Blues


I don’t live in a swing state.  I’m thankful for that.

I do live in a media market that borders a contested state, which is bad enough.  I’ve been subjected to more than a bearable share of TV ads, radio commercials, mailers, yard signs, and other political detritus.  I’ve been stunned by the pretension, the slander, the misrepresentation – not just of their opponents position but of their own!  

Yes, I’m thankful that I don’t live in a swing state.

But then again, I’m not.

Most peoptle are amazed and horrified to discover that a very few states, even a very few counties in a very few  states, get to decide the future.  That there are so few places where elections are actually contested.  That, in the end, so few votes really matter.

Not me.  No, I’m amazed and horrified that in the 21st Century, in the real world there are so many places where there is no battle, where elections are not contested, where most of the people think the same way and believe the same way and vote the same way.

The election results show us to be a closely divided nation.  But the truth is, in most places in this country, we are not divided at all.  Most red states are really, completely red.  Many blue states are deeply blue.  Rural areas are red.  Urban areas are blue.  White people are red.  Everyone else is not. 

This is not a good thing.

If this is a truly divided country, then it will be difficult to heal that division when most of us live so far away from the dividing line, when we are constantly confronted only by people on our own team, when we only converse with people who think like ourselves, when we are not in any real way exposed in some intimate fashion with ideas other than our own.  How can we heal our differences unless we connect to those who are different than us?  Who can admit that they are wrong when all of their neighbors say they are right?

We have entrenched our divisions geographically, racially, sexually.  Anger will replace concession, I fear.  Injury will fuel intransigence.  We will all crawl into our bunkers, load up on canned goods and sharpen our weapons for the next battle. 

And nothing will change. 

Which is, on the other hand, a good thing. 

Even in my despair I know the one thing that truly never changes.  The God who is bigger than our fat, stubborn egos.  That in the midst of our failures, our faults, our stiff necks and our sin, God remains steadfast, merciful, powerful.  That in the midst of what is merely the most recent breakdown of humanity, God’s will is still done, and we are saved.

And that even our worst will become the seed of the future. 

"When pride comes, then comes disgrace; but wisdom is with the humble." (Proverbs 11:2)

The gift of this election is an offered moment to step back and see ourselves for what we are, to confess the smallness of our dispute, to peer into the impending abyss and, horrified and shamed, stop.  Just stop.  Maybe shut our mouths.  Maybe fall to our knees.  Maybe humbled, and, if even by accident, discover the wisdom of our God.

And be covered by his grace and be saved.  From ourselves.  For each other.

I vote for that.

Saturday, September 15, 2012

Two simple words


There is a lot of anger in the world today.

All across the Middle East and North Africa particularly, rioting and burning and killing over a video offense against the faith of some, added to a long litany of oppression, occupation and poverty.  Cultures crossed with severity and insecurity have exploded into war and bloodshed. 

This is not new, of course.

And, I wonder, how much anger must lie behind the deliberate creation and promotion of a video designed purely to insult in the greatest way possible an entire religion, a whole people.  How much disconcert over acts of terrorism, how much grief over real and imagined suffering, how much contempt, determination to pain, to rile, to agitate.

Yes, the world is full of anger today.

And, of course, the anger of politician and pundit over responses to such events, to over-soft answer, to imagined apology.  To be weak, to be sorry, to offer aid or comfort to one’s enemies surely is to invite more violence, more terrorism, more death.

Which is not so. 

Let no evil talk come out of your mouths, but only what is useful for building up, as there is need, so that your words may give grace to those who hear. … Put away from you all bitterness and wrath and anger and wrangling and slander, together with all malice, and be kind to one another.”  Ephesians 4:29-32

In an angry world what greater weapon do we possess than our ability to apologize?  Do we truly believe that we can outshout one another, are we only able to match our enemies temper with our own, to meet their violence with our violence, to spill their blood for ours?  How will that change anything for the better?  How will that bring life to worlds caught in a mutual dance of death?

No!  Let us speak clearly that the end to anger is found only in a kind word, a gentle word, an outreached hand, a heartfelt apology.  The exit from this endless cycle of anger will not be found in more anger, we cannot judge the world into submission by our self-righteous sense of superiority.  We cannot change the world by being exactly as it already is.

We need apologies if we are to survive.  We need them because they are true.

Every angry word carries within it a lie, a denial of accountability even in a small way to the world which we have all helped to build.  No problem is truly one-sided, no resentment is completely undeserved, no hand is untainted with the blood of injustice in this world.  Apologies are, by definition, the truest words we utter, even if we are not fully aware of our own culpability.  The cross of Christ reminds us daily of the cost of our culpability.  Our unwillingness, our failure to apologize merely drives the nails in a little deeper. 

To refuse to apologize, to speak against apologies, is the greatest sin of all, and the risk of even greater destruction.  For which we should all be certainly sorry.