Thing two: Why do we have neighbors anyway?
No one comes into the world alone. Adam
lived in the very intimate presence of his creator, and the first thing God discovered
about Adam was how much he needed an other. A helper. And when none of the
creatures God made for Adam fulfilled that need, God did the most amazing
thing. God made from one, two. The same at a the most fundamental level, yet
also fully and truly discrete. A duplicate with distinction. Harmony within
individuality. And thus began the great conundrum that we call community.
We have a love/hate relationship with
other people. Sometimes at the same time. Our need to belong to and receive
recognition from others stands in contrast to our need to self-actualize as
individuals. Or at least we think it does. While modernity fancies the two in competition,
faith knows a greater truth: they are the hopelessly interwoven. Sacrifice for
another is the highest personal achievement for any human being. It defines us.
We are never our best selves until we are our best selves for someone else.
That is an uncomfortable paradox, so
much so that we have raised its antithesis to godlike status.
We believe and live as if self-actualization
is an individual work and a sole (not soul) reward. We suppose that the highest
value in this world – and especially in this nation – is to have no dependence
on others, neither obligation nor burden. We desire most to have agency in our
own life, to owe nothing to anyone, to earn what we have and keep what we get
and give nothing in return.
We will say that giving to others is a
fine thing. But works of charity as we practice them in this world mostly serve
to enhance our self-identity as “good” people or demonstrate our capacity for
empathy (an increasing hard-to-find virtue.) Yes, we care about important
causes, yes we care about other people, but charity is practiced in the
language of “us” and “them.” We write checks, we attend benefits, we put in
time at the local soup kitchen or food pantry, and then we return to our own
world, our own life, just as we left it.
Which, of course, all but guarantees
that the work is never done. It turns out that Jesus knew what he was talking
about when he told Judas, “you always have the poor with you.” (John 12:8 NRSV)
Maybe we like it this way? Jesus probably knew that we would fall in love with
ourselves to the detriment of our neighbor. Maybe he was just mocking the
disciples. Maybe he was testing them. Now, of course, it has become our
national mantra. Serving the poor becomes an opportunity to gain community
service cred without endangering the status quo.
Saul Alinski’s “Upstream Story”
captures our problem:
Imagine a large river with a high
waterfall. At the bottom of this waterfall hundreds of people are working
frantically trying to save those who have fallen into the river and have fallen
down the waterfall, many of them drowning. As the people along the shore are
trying to rescue as many as possible one individual looks up and sees a
seemingly never-ending stream of people falling down the waterfall and begins
to run upstream. One of other rescuers hollers, “Where are you going? There are
so many people that need help here.” To which the man replied, “I’m going
upstream to find out why so many people are falling into the river.”[1]
We want to help. That is a good
impulse. But it is a beginning, not an end. We are willing to give generously
to help others, up to but never beyond the costs of our independence. Never in
any way that touches us or actually alters our world. And so nothing really changes.
It’s fascinating how such a venerable value
has become our national shackle. “For freedom Christ has set us free,” Paul
wrote to the new Christians in Galatia. “Stand firm, therefore, and do not
submit again to a yoke of slavery.” (Galatians 5:1 NRSV) This conclusion to Paul’s
rant against self-righteous legalism evidently fell on deaf ears. Two millennia
later we still throw away the gift of grace for the fruitless and never-ending
endeavor of trying to make something good out of ourselves. Why? Are we so
disappointed with what God has made of us?
It seems that we are. We will never
find community in its fullest sense until we confront our inability to embrace
our connectedness with others. We are members of the same body, Paul reminds us,
acknowledging the necessity of each other, contributing to the common welfare,
rejoicing with the grateful and protecting the weak. But we can never realize
the fullness of this insight until we transform the way we live.
No easy thing.
We cannot be the people God made us to
be until we stop being the people we made ourselves to be. That work will
require us to name and confess deep, not-entirely subconscious “isms” that distance
us from our neighbor: racism, sexism, ageism, ableism. There are others. It is
a long list. We will have to finally and willfully own our history, tear down
its idolatrous monuments, stop pretending that its ghosts are not still
wandering the world’s streets right now. We will have to learn to say the words
“I’m wrong.” We will have to learn new ways to interact with family and friends
who lack the courage or grace to acknowledge the truth themselves.
And then we will be forced to go deeper.
Those sins are merely outward manifestations of the original sin, the belief
that our particular existence is, in and of itself, definitive. In the garden
the serpent tempted Adam and Eve with the promise of self-sufficiency. “You
will be like God,” (Genesis 3:5 NRSV) he assured them - independent agents,
knowing good and evil, fully endowed with the ability and the right to make our
own choices, in full control of the consequences. That cliché remains at the
heart of far too much of human behavior. We are so busy being ourselves that we
have no time or energy to be anything else. Community is just a dream, a
far-off dream.
Community should be more. It should be
our very identity. It should be as common to human life as breathing. It is the
spirit of our baptism and we need desperately to live it out. The failure of
the faithful to be what we were made to be, what we were saved to be, comes at
no small cost. It has been deadly to many, it has made life unbearable for all.
We have failed our mission, we have failed our neighbor, we have failed
ourselves. And we have no excuse. We know what we need to do.


